Skip to main content
eBay Logo

Shop by category

Advanced
    • eBay Deals
    • Help & Contact
    • Valentine's Day
    • Current language EnglishEnglish
      • Français
    • Sell
    • Watch ListExpand Watch List
      Loading...
      Sign in to see your user information
    • My eBayExpand My eBay
      • Summary
      • Recently Viewed
      • Bids/Offers
      • Watch List
      • Purchase History
      • Selling
      • Saved Searches
      • Saved Sellers
      • My Garage
      • Messages
    • Expand Cart
      Loading...
      Something went wrong. View cart for details.
    {"delay":300}

    There seems to be a problem serving the request at this time

    breadcrumb

    • eBay
    • Toys & Hobbies
    • Stuffed Animals
    • First & Main

    First & Main Stuffed Animals

    Side Refine Panel

    Shop by Category

    • Stuffed Animals
    • First & Main
    • Handmade
    • Animal Alley
    • Applause
    • Aurora
    • Coca-Cola
    • Dakin
    • Dan Dee
    • Disney
    • Eden
    • FAO Schwarz
    • Fisher Price
    • Gund
    • Hansa
    • Jellycat
    • Kookeys
    • Limited Treasures
    • Melissa & Doug
    • Neopets
    • Pound Puppies
    • Princess Soft Toys
      • Puffkins
      • Russ
      • Steiff
      • Uglydolls
      • Warner Bros.
      • Webkinz & Lil'Kinz
      • Vintage
      • Mixed Lots
      • Other Stuffed Animals
    LessView less categories
    • All

    • Auction

    • Buy It Now

    • Best Match
    • Time: ending soonest
    • Time: newly listed
    • Price + Shipping: lowest first
    • Price + Shipping: highest first
    • Distance: nearest first
    • List View

    973 Results

      • 3-4 Years
      • Small (6-14 in)
      • Medium (14-24 in)
      • Unbranded
      • All Listings filter applied
    • FIRST & MAIN "Arianna Bear" White Stuffed Plush 14" Teddy Bear No. 1205 Rare
      SPONSORED

      FIRST & MAIN "Arianna Bear" White Stuffed Plush 14" Teddy Bear No. 1205 Rare

      C $34.74
      C $9.49 shipping
    • Precious Pastel Multicolor Plush Teddy Bear 9" Soft Toy Stuffed #2344 CLEAN
      SPONSORED

      Precious Pastel Multicolor Plush Teddy Bear 9" Soft Toy Stuffed #2344 CLEAN

      C $29.62
      Was: C $39.48
      or Best Offer
    •  Plush Bear  "Tender Teddy" Brown w/ Patch Heart Cuddle Soft 12 inch
      SPONSORED

      Plush Bear "Tender Teddy" Brown w/ Patch Heart Cuddle Soft 12 inch

      (3)3 product ratings - Plush Bear "Tender Teddy" Brown w/ Patch Heart Cuddle Soft 12 inch
      C $13.44
      or Best Offer
    • White Teddy Bear My Hearts A Flutter with thoughts Of You First & Main TOODLES
      SPONSORED

      White Teddy Bear My Hearts A Flutter with thoughts Of You First & Main TOODLES

      C $31.26
      Was: C $35.52
      or Best Offer
    • Vintage Teddy Bear Plush Cream Shaggy with clothing Lot

      Vintage Teddy Bear Plush Cream Shaggy with clothing Lot

      C $13.46
      0 bids
      C $25.00 shipping
      Ending Saturday at 14:03 EST4d 10h
      or Best Offer
    • Vtg First & Main 8in. "RARE HARE" Bunny Rabbit Plush Corduroy Ears Easter Spring

      Vtg First & Main 8in. "RARE HARE" Bunny Rabbit Plush Corduroy Ears Easter Spring

      C $15.34
      Was: C $17.42
      or Best Offer
    • NWT FIRST AND MAIN FLOPPY  LONG LIMBO LEGS LANKYDOODLE ELEPHANT PLUSH GRAY

      NWT FIRST AND MAIN FLOPPY LONG LIMBO LEGS LANKYDOODLE ELEPHANT PLUSH GRAY

      C $20.18
      C $20.67 shipping
      or Best Offer
    •  Plush Beige Teddy Bear First & Main w/TILLIE Bow

      Plush Beige Teddy Bear First & Main w/TILLIE Bow

      C $9.35
      C $22.46 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • White Teddy Bear With Ribbon FIRST AND MAIN 1684 DENA SOFT HUGGABLE-NWT PLUSH B1

      White Teddy Bear With Ribbon FIRST AND MAIN 1684 DENA SOFT HUGGABLE-NWT PLUSH B1

      C $20.18
      or Best Offer
    • Moose Plush 14" First & Main Spruced Jointed Moose Beanbag Scarf Overalls

      Moose Plush 14" First & Main Spruced Jointed Moose Beanbag Scarf Overalls

      C $1.33
      0 bidsEnding 12 Feb at 21:54 EST5d 18h
    • First & Main Sly Sloth V7635 You are Slow Beautiful to me heart plush stuffed 

      First & Main Sly Sloth V7635 You are Slow Beautiful to me heart plush stuffed 

      C $6.05
      0 bids
      or Best Offer
      Ending Thursday at 14:15 EST2d 10h
    • First & Main Floppy Friends Pink Corduroy Feet Pig Plush Stuffed Toy 11" Tall

      First & Main Floppy Friends Pink Corduroy Feet Pig Plush Stuffed Toy 11" Tall

      C $21.39
      or Best Offer
    • Pink Glitterbear 9" Teddy Bear Plush w/Flower Rose First and Main Stuffed Animal

      Pink Glitterbear 9" Teddy Bear Plush w/Flower Rose First and Main Stuffed Animal

      C $39.02
      C $23.63 shipping
    • 9 Inch Giraffe Rattle for Girl/Baby Rattle/Plush Rattle/Baby Shower Gift/Newborn
      SPONSORED

      9 Inch Giraffe Rattle for Girl/Baby Rattle/Plush Rattle/Baby Shower Gift/Newborn

      (1)1 product ratings - 9 Inch Giraffe Rattle for Girl/Baby Rattle/Plush Rattle/Baby Shower Gift/Newborn
      C $13.44
      C $29.41 shipping
    • First & Main Lion and the Lamb 10" Plush Peacemakers Stuffed Animal
      SPONSORED

      First & Main Lion and the Lamb 10" Plush Peacemakers Stuffed Animal

      C $60.94
      C $32.83 shipping
    • First & Main Great Smoky Mountains Bear Plush Teddy Bear  (#7723), 9 inch
      SPONSORED

      First & Main Great Smoky Mountains Bear Plush Teddy Bear (#7723), 9 inch

      C $18.70
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Jingles Blue Giraffe Plush Rattle 9" 2773 Stuffed Animal Toy

      First & Main Jingles Blue Giraffe Plush Rattle 9" 2773 Stuffed Animal Toy

      C $12.04
      C $20.21 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Lil’ Easter Huggums Rabbit Bunny Brown Pink Bow 12.5” #E4200

      First & Main Lil’ Easter Huggums Rabbit Bunny Brown Pink Bow 12.5” #E4200

      C $16.15
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main White Dena Teddy Bear Plush 10 Inches With Tag

      First & Main White Dena Teddy Bear Plush 10 Inches With Tag

      C $13.46
      C $14.80 shipping
    • First and Main Fantazoo Plush ELENA the ELEPHANT  7” Orange Sparkle Glitter Eyes

      First and Main Fantazoo Plush ELENA the ELEPHANT 7” Orange Sparkle Glitter Eyes

      C $16.13
      C $20.33 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First and & Main "Scraggles" Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Red bow #1114

      First and & Main "Scraggles" Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Red bow #1114

      C $12.10
      0 bids
      C $29.56 shipping
      Ending Today at 20:17 EST16h 27m
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Jackrabbits Vintage Plush Animal Bunny Rabbit Brown Laying Down

      First & Main Jackrabbits Vintage Plush Animal Bunny Rabbit Brown Laying Down

      C $26.90
      or Best Offer
    • First and Main Plush Rainbow Birthday Bear Green With Green Bow EUC

      First and Main Plush Rainbow Birthday Bear Green With Green Bow EUC

      C $17.48
      or Best Offer
    • Sorbet Teddy First and Main Bear Pastel Rainbow Colors Lace Feet Plush Toy

      Sorbet Teddy First and Main Bear Pastel Rainbow Colors Lace Feet Plush Toy

      C $30.21
      Was: C $33.57
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main FantaZoo  Green With Purple Polka Dot Charlee Cheetah Plush Animal

      First & Main FantaZoo Green With Purple Polka Dot Charlee Cheetah Plush Animal

      C $16.42
      or Best Offer
    • Plush ThanksGiving TURKEY Stuffed Animal Macy's Day Parade FIRST & MAIN 12" TOM

      Plush ThanksGiving TURKEY Stuffed Animal Macy's Day Parade FIRST & MAIN 12" TOM

      C $26.75
    • First & Main OATMEAL Bunny Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animal NON-ALLERGENIC Tan Tags 2

      First & Main OATMEAL Bunny Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animal NON-ALLERGENIC Tan Tags 2

      C $33.63
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Pajama Pal Bear Plush Lovey Security Blanket 12" Stuffed Animal Toy

      First & Main Pajama Pal Bear Plush Lovey Security Blanket 12" Stuffed Animal Toy

      C $13.39
      C $20.22 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Wuffles Poodle Plush New White Dog First and Main Handcrafted 2002
      SPONSORED

      Wuffles Poodle Plush New White Dog First and Main Handcrafted 2002

      C $20.18
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Ellie Elephant Baby w/ Bandage & Handkerchief 12" Long Plush
      SPONSORED

      First & Main Ellie Elephant Baby w/ Bandage & Handkerchief 12" Long Plush

      C $16.15
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main BROWN SHAGGY REGIS TEDDY BEAR w/ Pink Bow STUFFED PLUSH TOY New NWT
      SPONSORED

      First & Main BROWN SHAGGY REGIS TEDDY BEAR w/ Pink Bow STUFFED PLUSH TOY New NWT

      C $33.63
      C $25.57 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Plush Stuffed Bear CHUCKLEBEARY First & Main USA 12" Brown w Tags NON TOXIC Cute
      SPONSORED

      Plush Stuffed Bear CHUCKLEBEARY First & Main USA 12" Brown w Tags NON TOXIC Cute

      C $15.41
    • Rare 2002 "Francesca the Frog" Ballerina Bean Bag Plush Long Leg Toy 20" L@@K

      Rare 2002 "Francesca the Frog" Ballerina Bean Bag Plush Long Leg Toy 20" L@@K

      C $26.90
      or Best Offer
    • Plush Bear  "Tender Teddy" Brown w/ Patch Heart Cuddle Soft 14” Valentines

      Plush Bear "Tender Teddy" Brown w/ Patch Heart Cuddle Soft 14” Valentines

      (3)3 product ratings - Plush Bear "Tender Teddy" Brown w/ Patch Heart Cuddle Soft 14” Valentines
      C $13.39
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Chumley Brown Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 8” Tall  Tan

      First & Main Chumley Brown Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 8” Tall Tan

      C $17.48
      or Best Offer
    • Adorable Plush Stuffed Bear - about 9 1/2" tall - Burgundy color

      Adorable Plush Stuffed Bear - about 9 1/2" tall - Burgundy color

      C $14.69
      Was: C $16.15
      C $13.86 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First and Main 'Minky' 9" Gray Plush Teddy Bear w/ Corduroy Paws FREE SHIPPING

      First and Main 'Minky' 9" Gray Plush Teddy Bear w/ Corduroy Paws FREE SHIPPING

      C $17.47
      C $13.90 shipping
    • FIRST & MAIN BABY GIRL PINK BLUE YELLOW RATTLE Nubby Elephant Plush NURSERY Toy

      FIRST & MAIN BABY GIRL PINK BLUE YELLOW RATTLE Nubby Elephant Plush NURSERY Toy

      C $26.88
      or Best Offer
    • FIRST & MAIN Amanda Easter Bunny Cream & Pastel Colors Plush Stuffed Animal 14"
      SPONSORED

      FIRST & MAIN Amanda Easter Bunny Cream & Pastel Colors Plush Stuffed Animal 14"

      C $10.76
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Tumbles Brown Bear Plush 7" 1124 Stuffed Animal Toy
      SPONSORED

      First & Main Tumbles Brown Bear Plush 7" 1124 Stuffed Animal Toy

      C $35.83
      Was: C $38.95
      C $20.56 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First and Main Bear plush named Smedley #1814

      First and Main Bear plush named Smedley #1814

      C $18.84
      C $13.91 shipping
    • Unlucky Ducky, First and Main plush duck with sling and bandage, get well

      Unlucky Ducky, First and Main plush duck with sling and bandage, get well

      C $21.52
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Bear Plush Lot of 2 Puddin and Lil Puddin Merry Christmas Scarf

      First & Main Bear Plush Lot of 2 Puddin and Lil Puddin Merry Christmas Scarf

      C $21.52
      or Best Offer
    • First Main Fanta Sea Tallulah Turtle Plush Purple Pink Glitter Sparkle 7"

      First Main Fanta Sea Tallulah Turtle Plush Purple Pink Glitter Sparkle 7"

      C $20.17
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Stuffed Animal Rare Bear

      First & Main Stuffed Animal Rare Bear

      C $2.68
      0 bids
      C $22.89 shipping
      Ending Thursday at 19:40 EST2d 15h
    • Teddy Bear “Chumley” Plush Stuffed Animal Sitting 11” Chubby Pot Belly Weighted

      Teddy Bear “Chumley” Plush Stuffed Animal Sitting 11” Chubby Pot Belly Weighted

      C $41.97
      Was: C $64.57
      C $71.03 shipping
    • First & Main Cream Blue Softstuff Bear Plush Soft Lovey #2324 Stitched Eyes Gift

      First & Main Cream Blue Softstuff Bear Plush Soft Lovey #2324 Stitched Eyes Gift

      C $26.90
      Was: C $33.63
    • First and Main MINKY Bear Plush Brown Teddy Stuffed Animal Toy 7" NWT

      First and Main MINKY Bear Plush Brown Teddy Stuffed Animal Toy 7" NWT

      C $18.82
      C $17.08 shipping
      or Best Offer

    Results Pagination - Page 1

    1. 1
    2. 2
    3. 3
    4. 4
    5. 5
    6. 6
    7. 7
    8. 8
    9. 9
    10. 10

    Additional site navigation

    • About eBay
    • Announcements
    • Community
    • Security Centre
    • Seller centre
    • Policies
    • Help & contact
    • Site Map
    Copyright © 1995-2023 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. User Agreement, Privacy, Payments Terms of Use, Cookies and AdChoice