Skip to main content
Hi
!
Hi!
Sign in
or
register
eBay Deals
Help & Contact
Select Language. Current:
English
Français
Sell
Watch List
Expand watch list
My eBay
Expand My eBay
Summary
Recently Viewed
Bids/Offers
Watch List
Purchase History
Selling
Saved Feed
Saved Searches
Saved Sellers
My Garage
Messages
Expand Notifications
Please
sign-in
to view notifications.
Expand Cart
Loading...
eBay Home
Shop by category
All Categories
Search
Advanced
Jay Cutler Trading Cards
Shop by card
See all
2015 Panini Crown Royale Jay Cutler #93
2012 Panini Contenders Jay Cutler #17
2014 Topps Prime Jay Cutler #41
2009 Donruss Classics Jay Cutler #2
2006 Topps Draft Picks and Prospects (DPP) Jay Cutler #CM-JC
2009 SP Signature Edition Jay Cutler #43
2007 Topps Jay Cutler #GN-JC2
2010 Panini Threads Jay Cutler #25
2007 Score Jay Cutler #248
2008 Upper Deck Jay Cutler #58
2010 Topps Supreme Jay Cutler #99
2006 Topps Total Jay Cutler #464
2006 SP Authentic Jay Cutler #CH-JC
2008 Donruss Threads Jay Cutler #PGK-45
2009 Donruss Classics Jay Cutler #33
2011 Score Jay Cutler #52
2009 Donruss Elite Jay Cutler #31
2014 Score Jay Cutler #309
2010 Panini Gridiron Gear Jay Cutler #11
2013 Topps Mini Jay Cutler #54
2013 Panini Crown Royale Jay Cutler #45
2009 Topps Jay Cutler #45
2009 Donruss Gridiron Gear Jay Cutler #42
2013 Topps Inception Jay Cutler #76
Show 12 more
Show 12 more
More to explore
1991 Baseball Playing Cards In Baseball Trading Cards
Aba Basketball In Basketball Trading Cards
Afl Football In Football Trading Cards
Aj Pierzynski In Baseball Trading Cards
Aubrey Plaza In Baseball Trading Cards
Auburn Football In Football Trading Cards
Baseball Cards Magazine In Baseball Trading Cards
Bash Brothers In Baseball Trading Cards
Bazooka Gum In Baseball Trading Cards
Bill Belichick In Football Trading Cards
Bill Romanowski In Football Trading Cards
Billy Beane In Baseball Trading Cards
Billy Cannon In Football Trading Cards
Blaster Box In Basketball Trading Cards
Bo Knows In Baseball Trading Cards
Bob Hayes In Football Trading Cards
Brian Scalabrine In Basketball Trading Cards
Bronko Nagurski In Football Trading Cards
Carl Banks In Football Trading Cards
Charlie Ward In Football Trading Cards
Cliff Branch In Football Trading Cards
Collectors Choice In Baseball Trading Cards
Collectors Choice In Basketball Trading Cards
Conlon Baseball Trading Cards
Cooperstown In Baseball Trading Cards
Danny Ainge In Baseball Trading Cards
Danny Ainge In Basketball Trading Cards
Darren Woodson In Football Trading Cards
Dizzy Dean In Baseball Trading Cards
Dock Ellis In Baseball Trading Cards
Drazen Petrovic In Basketball Trading Cards
Eden Hazard In Soccer Trading Cards
Estate Sale Cards In Baseball Trading Cards
Fab Five In Basketball Trading Cards
Fleer Ultra In Baseball Trading Cards
Fleer Ultra In Basketball Trading Cards
Fleer Ultra In Football Trading Cards
Football Playbook In Football Trading Cards
Gabby Hartnett In Baseball Trading Cards
Gems Of The Game In Baseball Trading Cards
Gems Of The Game In Basketball Trading Cards
Gems Of The Game In Football Trading Cards
Heisman Trophy In Football Trading Cards
Iu Basketball In Basketball Trading Cards
Jack Lambert In Football Trading Cards
Jack Tatum In Football Trading Cards
Japan Wrestling In Wrestling Trading Cards
Japanese Baseball In Baseball Trading Cards
Jason Elam In Football Trading Cards
Jerry Kramer In Football Trading Cards
John Daly In Golf Trading Cards
Jordan Patch In Basketball Trading Cards
Kam Chancellor In Football Trading Cards
Kenny Easley In Football Trading Cards
Lc Greenwood In Football Trading Cards
Lefty Grove In Baseball Trading Cards
Lester Hayes In Football Trading Cards
Lewandowski Soccer Trading Cards
Manute Bol In Basketball Trading Cards
Marilyn Monroe Cards In Baseball Trading Cards
Merril Hoge In Football Trading Cards
Mickey Mantle Ceramic Card In Baseball Trading Cards
Mike Rozier In Football Trading Cards
Mike Tyson Card In Baseball Trading Cards
Mini Jersey In Basketball Trading Cards
Moe Berg In Baseball Trading Cards
Nba On Nbc In Basketball Trading Cards
Nfl Europe In Football Trading Cards
Olympic Cards In Basketball Trading Cards
Panini Redemption In Baseball Trading Cards
Panini Redemption In Basketball Trading Cards
Penny Hardaway In Basketball Trading Cards
Perez Steele In Baseball Trading Cards
Pj Tucker In Basketball Trading Cards
President Trading Cards In Baseball Trading Cards
Prizm Auto In Football Trading Cards
Pro Bowl In Football Trading Cards
Roddy Piper In Wrestling Trading Cards
Sarunas Marciulionis In Basketball Trading Cards
Scott Radinsky In Baseball Trading Cards
Sebastian Janikowski In Football Trading Cards
Shaq Autograph In Basketball Trading Cards
Sid Luckman In Football Trading Cards
Steve Tasker In Football Trading Cards
Sugar Daddy Cards In Basketball Trading Cards
The Miz In Wrestling Trading Cards
Tony Boselli In Football Trading Cards
Topps Poster In Baseball Trading Cards
Trading Card Display Case In Baseball Trading Cards
Triple H In Wrestling Trading Cards
Unc Basketball In Basketball Trading Cards
Undertaker Indiana Wrestling Trading Cards
Unopened Tobacco In Baseball Trading Cards
Uva Basketball In Basketball Trading Cards
Walmart Exclusive In Baseball Trading Cards
Wax Box In Baseball Trading Cards
Wax Case In Baseball Trading Cards
Wcw Nitro In Wrestling Trading Cards
Wilbert Montgomery In Football Trading Cards
Zlatan Ibrahimovic In Soccer Trading Cards
Shop by category
Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop
Sports Trading Cards
Box & Case Breaks
Card Lots
Complete Sets
NFTs
Price Guides & Publications
Sealed Boxes
Sealed Cases
Sealed Packs
Single Cards
Storage & Display Supplies
Uncut Sheets
Wrappers & Empty Card Boxes
breadcrumb
eBay
Collectibles & Art
Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop
Collectibles & Art
Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop
Sports Trading Cards
Jay Cutler
2025 Weird Cardz Collective - Jay Cutler "SMOKIN' JAY" /5
Pre-Owned
C $533.36
or Best Offer
2011 PANINI GOLD STANDARD JAY CUTLER AUTO 14K GOLD LEAF STARS 2/2 PSA 9 MINT
New (Other)
·
Panini
C $413.45
C $27.00 shipping
11 watching
2014 Panini Football Prizm Gold Jay Cutler /10 Air Marshall #AM12
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $261.86
or Best Offer
11 watching
2020 Mosaic JERSEY NUMBER MATCH 54/99 Blue Prizm SP Brian Urlacher Chicago Bears
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $48.24
or Best Offer
C $21.75 shipping
2013 Panini Playbook Signatures Blue /25 Jay Cutler #6 Auto
Fulfilled by COMC - World’s largest consignment service
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $111.68
C $26.35 shipping
13 watching
2014 Panini Select Stars Jersey Relic Orange Prizm /50 Jay Cutler #SS-JC
Fulfilled by COMC - World’s largest consignment service
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $1.36
C $18.96 shipping
1 bid
1d 22h
2006 Press Pass Jay Cutler Rookie Red Ink Sapphire Inscription Auto RC SP /50
Pre-Owned
·
Press Pass
C $55.11
2012 Jay Cutler National Treasures #/99 Card Chicago Bears
Pre-Owned
C $9.65
2006 SPX #159 JAY CUTLER RC /1299 BGS 9.5 GEM MINT ROOKIE BRONCOS BEARS DOLPHINS
New (Other)
·
Upper Deck
C $22.04
or Best Offer
2007 Topps Chrome - Jay Cutler #TC4
Pre-Owned
·
Topps
C $1.38
C $16.21 shipping
0 bids
4d 21h
2009 Topps Finest Jay Cutler #23 Gold Refractor /75 Chicago Bears
Pre-Owned
·
Topps
C $48.24
2005 UD Exquisite John Elway Jay Cutler Combo Sigs Gold /20
Pre-Owned
C $413.46
or Best Offer
New Listing
2006 Topps Football Jay Cutler NFL 8306 #NFL8 RC Denver Broncos
Pre-Owned
·
Topps
C $1.36
or Best Offer
C $16.57 shipping
0 bids
6d 12h
2006 Bowman Sterling Dual Rookie Auto Jay Culter/Kellen Clemons #/50 9.5/10 👍👍
New (Other)
·
Bowman
C $274.26
or Best Offer
Rare! 2006 FLEER ULTRA EXCLUSIVE ROOKIES AutographJAY CUTLER LUCKY 13 RC AUTO SP
Pre-Owned
·
Fleer
C $274.34
or Best Offer
2013 Topps Museum Collection Jay Cutler Game Used NFL Shield One Of One 1/1
Pre-Owned
·
Topps
C $1,378.20
10 watching
JAY CUTLER SSP /25 MIRROR RED REFRACTOR HOLO 2014 TOTALLY CERTIFIED BEARS RARE!
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $274.26
or Best Offer
A1148- 2011 Topps Chrome FB Cards 1-220 +Rookies -You Pick- 15+ FREE US SHIP
Pre-Owned
C $1.51
to
C $36.40
C $4.15 shipping
2008 Topps Rookie Progression Bronze #9 Jay Cutler /389 PSA 9 (Pop 1)
New (Other)
·
Topps
C $165.37
or Best Offer
Jay Cutler signed 2014 Crown Royale #SI-JC patch auto jersey #6/15 Chicago Bears
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $835.27
or Best Offer
10 watching
2010 Topps Supreme Football Jay Cutler /200 #99
Pre-Owned
·
Topps
C $1.36
1 bid
3d 12h
2013 Momentum #10 Marshall Cutler Forte Triple Feature Materials Prime /20
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $110.24
or Best Offer
C $24.26 shipping
JAY CUTLER 2011 TOTALLY CERTIFIED PIECE OF THE GAME LAUNDRY TAG GU PATCH #1/18
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $103.35
C $17.86 shipping
New Listing
🔥 2006 SAGE Game Exclusive SILVER AUTO SP #A10 Jay Cutler #d /50 VERY RARE!🔥
Pre-Owned
·
SAGE
C $20.67
C $17.14 shipping
0 bids
4d 21h
2017 Panini National Treasures Purple 44/75 Jay Cutler #50 Miami Dolphins
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $5.51
1 bid
4d 13h
Jay Cutler 2006 Sage Aspire Autograph #8/25 (Rc)
Pre-Owned
C $26.17
or Best Offer
C $17.30 shipping
JAY CUTLER 2010 Panini Plates & Patches NFL SHIELD PATCH AUTO #1/1 GAME WORN
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $2,065.92
or Best Offer
C $90.42 shipping
27 watching
2016 Panini Absolute Jay Cutler Chicago Bears #74
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $1.38
or Best Offer
0 bids
21h 30m
2014 Topps Finest 2014 Pulsar Refractors - JAY CUTLER #10 /25
Pre-Owned
·
Topps
C $39.99
or Best Offer
C $3.24 shipping
2007 Donruss Playoff Threads 1/1 Auto BRONCOS BEARS 2nd Year
Pre-Owned
·
Donruss
C $137.81
C $27.00 shipping
1 bid
20h 25m
2006 Donruss Elite Jay Cutler RC #/24 Broncos Bears Dolphins Vanderbilt SCARCE
Pre-Owned
·
Donruss
C $96.41
C $22.82 shipping
JAY CUTLER 2007 Panini Playoff National Treasures Game Used NFL Shield Auto 1/1
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $1,371.31
33 watching
2006 Bowman Chrome Jay Cutler Gold Refractor #222 /50 PSA 10 Rookie RC
New (Other)
·
Bowman
C $526.47
or Best Offer
C $42.32 shipping
16 watching
2006 PLAYOFF CONTENDERS PLAYOFF TICKET /25 JAY CUTLER RC PSA 10 POP 1
New (Other)
·
Playoff
C $330.75
or Best Offer
C $32.81 shipping
2007 Upper Deck JAY CUTLER Signed Card autograph auto BEARS BRONCOS
C $55.11
C $19.17 shipping
2006 Leaf Limited #258 Gold Spotlight Jay Cutler Auto Game Worn Patch RC 9/10
Pre-Owned
·
Donruss
C $17.23
C $21.17 shipping
6 bids
2d 17h
2006 Bowman Chrome X-Fractor /250 Jay Cutler #222 Rookie RC
Pre-Owned
·
Topps
C $27.55
or Best Offer
C $17.48 shipping
2006 Topps Chrome — #229 — Jay Cutler RC — PSA 10 Denver Broncos Chicago Bears
New (Other)
·
Topps
C $61.95
J. Cutler/C.jackson/L.Maroney 2006 Hot Prospects Endorsements RC Auto /25 Psa 9
New (Other)
·
Fleer
C $110.26
or Best Offer
2006 SPX NFL - Jay Cutler RC /1299 - BGS 9.5 Gem Mint - Broncos Bears Dolphins
New (Other)
C $29.99
or Best Offer
C $2.99 shipping
2008 Leaf Certified Materials - Jay Cutler #37 Mirror Red /100
Pre-Owned
C $4.34
0 bids
5d 18h
2017 Panini Illusions Blue #55 Dan Marino Jay Cutler /100 Trophy Collection
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $48.22
C $16.24 shipping
Chicago Bears Football Cards - Choose from 100s Player Qty Discount - Part 1
Pre-Owned
C $2.47
to
C $2.74
C $4.82 shipping
New Listing
2006 Press Pass Legends Bronze Jay Cutler 739/999 #B51A A6
Pre-Owned
C $1.36
C $17.26 shipping
0 bids
6d 19h
2014 Certified Jersey Materials Jay Cutler Jersey 1 color Chicago Bears #MJC
Pre-Owned
C $6.85
C $16.73 shipping
2012 Panini Black Materials Triples Bears Giants Hakeem Nicks Jay Cutler 3/3!
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $137.82
or Best Offer
2006 JAY CUTLER #159 SPx ROOKIE GOLD RC AUTO 187/1299 PSA 10 Gem Mint Broncos
New (Other)
·
Upper Deck
C $205.35
or Best Offer
C $48.42 shipping
2006 Topps Team Set Jay Cutler (RC) PSA 10 GEM MT 🔥
New (Other)
·
Topps
C $41.35
or Best Offer
2004 Topps Finest Tommie Harris RC Gold Refractor X Fractor 45/150
Pre-Owned
·
Topps
C $41.35
or Best Offer
C $22.92 shipping
13 watching
2016 Panini Select Field Level Tie-Dye Prizm /25 Jay Cutler #259
Fulfilled by COMC - World’s largest consignment service
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $45.92
C $24.42 shipping
2011 Panini Timeless Treasures Material Jerseys /250 Jay Cutler #42
Fulfilled by COMC - World’s largest consignment service
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $5.90
C $19.10 shipping
New Listing
2017 National Treasures Jarvis Landry Jay Cutler Jersey Patch Materials Relic🔥
Pre-Owned
·
Panini
C $7.92
C $21.93 shipping
0 bids
6d 19h
Jay Cutler 2006 Score Rookie BGS 9.5 #350 RC Gem Denver Broncos Chicago Bears
New (Other)
·
Donruss/Playoff
C $13.77
or Best Offer
2006 Absolute JAY CUTLER Rookie SPECTRUM GOLD 18/25 RC Card # 214 PSA 8 Pop 1
New (Other)
C $49.31
or Best Offer
2007 SPx #30 Jay Cutler
Pre-Owned
C $2.47
C $16.70 shipping
0 bids
20h 36m
Jay Cutler 2007 Score 472/600 Gold Zone Franchise #F-6 Broncos
Pre-Owned
·
Donruss/Playoff
C $1.36
C $16.01 shipping
0 bids
1d 19h
2006 Playoff Contenders Jay Cutler #152 Rookie Ticket RC AUTO Autograph Broncos
Pre-Owned
C $44.09
Was:
C $55.11
was - C $55.11
C $16.11 shipping
2006 Playoff Contenders Football Jay Cutler #152 RC Rookie Auto BGS 9
New (Other)
C $62.01
or Best Offer
C $23.94 shipping
2006 Topps Team Sets #DEN12 Jay Cutler Denver Broncos Rookie Card BCCG 10 MINT
New (Other)
·
Topps
C $82.68
or Best Offer
C $17.24 shipping
2006 SAGE Aspire 5 Star Autograph #FS-9A Jay Cutler RC Vanderbilt /25
Pre-Owned
C $29.27
Was:
C $34.44
was - C $34.44
or Best Offer
C $15.09 shipping
Results Pagination - Page 1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
All Listings
Auction
Buy It Now
Sort: Best Match
Best Match
Time: ending soonest
Time: newly listed
Price + Shipping: lowest first
Price + Shipping: highest first
Distance: nearest first
List View
Gallery View
10,920 results
Sort: Best Match
Best Match
Time: ending soonest
Time: newly listed
Price + Shipping: lowest first
Price + Shipping: highest first
Distance: nearest first
Filter
2 filters applied
Player/Athlete: Jay Cutler
- Selected
Sport: Football
- Selected
Player/Athlete
Jay Cutler
Tom Brady
Joe Burrow
Patrick Mahomes II
Trevor Lawrence
Josh Allen
Patrick Mahomes
Aaron Rodgers
Justin Herbert
Barry Sanders
Brett Favre
Peyton Manning
Joe Montana
Jalen Hurts
Lamar Jackson
Jerry Rice
Dan Marino
C. J. Stroud
Emmitt Smith
Ja'Marr Chase
Sport
Football
Baseball
Basketball
Bowling
Bowls
Ice Hockey
Cycling
Weight Lifting
Aikido
Athletics
Golf
Running
Soccer
Set
2006 Topps
2014 Topps Chrome
2006 Score
2015 Panini Prizm
2005 Topps
2012 Topps
2015 Topps Chrome
2015 Score
2006 Press Pass
2007 Donruss Playoff
2007 Topps
2013 Score
2006 Upper Deck
2011 Topps Chrome
2007 Leaf Rookies & Stars
2006 Bowman
2008 Score
2013 Topps Chrome
2006 Topps Draft Picks and Prospects (DPP)
2014 Topps
League
National Football League (NFL)
National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA)
Heros
Major League (MLB)
National Basketball Association (NBA)
K-1
National Hockey League (NHL)
NCAA Division 1
FIFA Club World Cup
Glory
Serie A
AFC Champions League
FIFA Womens World Cup
FIFA World Cup
NASCAR
National League
PRIDE
Serie C
Strikeforce
Not Specified
Card Condition
Near Mint or Better
Excellent
Very Good
Poor
Not Specified
Condition
New
Used
Not Specified
Price
C $0.01 to C $4,823.70
All Filters
