Skip to main content
eBay Logo

Shop by category

Advanced
    • eBay Deals
    • Help & Contact
    • Current language EnglishEnglish
      • Français
    • Sell
    • Watch ListExpand Watch List
      Loading...
      Sign in to see your user information
    • My eBayExpand My eBay
      • Summary
      • Recently Viewed
      • Bids/Offers
      • Watch List
      • Purchase History
      • Selling
      • Saved Searches
      • Saved Sellers
      • My Garage
      • Messages
    • Expand Cart
      Loading...
      Something went wrong. View cart for details.
    {"delay":300}

    There seems to be a problem serving the request at this time

    breadcrumb

    • eBay
    • Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop
    • Autographs-Original
    • Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) Baltimore Colts Original Sports Autographed Items

    Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) Baltimore Colts Original Sports Autographed Items

    Side Refine Panel

    Shop by Category

    • Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop
    • Autographs-Original
    • Baseball-MLB
    • Basketball-NBA
    • Basketball-WNBA
    • Boxing
    • College-NCAA
    • Display Cases
    • Football-NFL
    • Golf-LPGA
    • Golf-PGA
    • Golf-Other
    • Hockey-NHL
    • Hockey-Other
    • Mixed Martial Arts (MMA)
    • Olympics
    • Racing-Formula 1
    • Racing-NASCAR
    • Racing-NHRA
    • Racing-Other
    • Rugby
    • Soccer
      • Tennis
      • Wrestling
      • Other Autographed Sports Mem
    • All

    • Auction

    • Buy It Now

    • Best Match
    • Time: ending soonest
    • Time: newly listed
    • Price + Shipping: lowest first
    • Price + Shipping: highest first
    • Distance: nearest first
    • List View

    152 Results

      • Autograph Authentication: Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) filter applied
      • Team: Baltimore Colts filter applied
      Clear All
      • Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) filter applied
      • Baltimore Colts filter applied
      • All Listings filter applied
    • George Kunz signed autographed jersey NFL Baltimore Colts PSA COA

      George Kunz signed autographed jersey NFL Baltimore Colts PSA COA

      C $130.83
      Was: C $163.54
      C $35.44 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Ted Hendricks autographed signed 8x10 photo NFL Baltimore Colts PSA COA

      Ted Hendricks autographed signed 8x10 photo NFL Baltimore Colts PSA COA

      C $49.07
      Was: C $61.33
      C $27.26 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • NFL Johnny Unitas signed autographed 4x6 index card BAS LOA COA COLTS QB Beckett

      NFL Johnny Unitas signed autographed 4x6 index card BAS LOA COA COLTS QB Beckett

      C $170.37
      C $66.01 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Johnny Unitas Baltimore Colts Signed 2001 Topps Archives 1957

      Johnny Unitas Baltimore Colts Signed 2001 Topps Archives 1957

      C $681.46
      Was: C $817.76
      C $27.90 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Johnny Unitas Signed Goal Line Art Card GLAC Autographed Colts PSA/DNA AL85297

      Johnny Unitas Signed Goal Line Art Card GLAC Autographed Colts PSA/DNA AL85297

      C $681.41
      or Best Offer
    • Lenny Moore  Colts HOF 1950 All Decade Team Signed Leather Mini Helmet PSA DNA

      Lenny Moore Colts HOF 1950 All Decade Team Signed Leather Mini Helmet PSA DNA

      C $200.35
      Was: C $954.05
      C $35.29 shipping
    • Alan Ameche Baltimore Colts Autographed Index Card PSA  slab 1954 Heisman

      Alan Ameche Baltimore Colts Autographed Index Card PSA slab 1954 Heisman

      C $245.32
      C $25.39 shipping
    • Johnny Unitas Colts Signed Autograph White Panel Wilson NFL Football PSA DNA

      Johnny Unitas Colts Signed Autograph White Panel Wilson NFL Football PSA DNA

      C $408.87
      C $34.02 shipping
    • Lenny Moore Raymond Berry Marchetti Art Donovan SIGNED Colts Mini Helmet PSA/DNA

      Lenny Moore Raymond Berry Marchetti Art Donovan SIGNED Colts Mini Helmet PSA/DNA

      C $388.44
      C $49.07 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • JOHNNY UNITAS Signed Baltimore COLTS Mini helmet #19  PSA/Dna

      JOHNNY UNITAS Signed Baltimore COLTS Mini helmet #19 PSA/Dna

      C $613.31
      C $43.23 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Art Donovan Signed Photo 8x10 Autographed Colts PSA/DNA

      Art Donovan Signed Photo 8x10 Autographed Colts PSA/DNA

      C $34.01
      or Best Offer
    • Art Donovan Baltimore Colts HOF Autographed Auto Signed 8x10 Photo ~ PSA/DNA

      Art Donovan Baltimore Colts HOF Autographed Auto Signed 8x10 Photo ~ PSA/DNA

      C $40.82
      C $20.91 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • 7x HOF Auto FS Authentic Helmet Unitas Moore Donavon Berry Baltimore Colts

      7x HOF Auto FS Authentic Helmet Unitas Moore Donavon Berry Baltimore Colts

      C $4,768.96
      or Best Offer
    • Johnny Unitas Signed Colts Football 8x10 Photo PSA/DNA COA Picture Autograph HOF

      Johnny Unitas Signed Colts Football 8x10 Photo PSA/DNA COA Picture Autograph HOF

      C $272.58
      C $27.18 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Raymond Berry autographed signed inscribed 8x10 photo NFL Baltimore Colts PSA

      Raymond Berry autographed signed inscribed 8x10 photo NFL Baltimore Colts PSA

      C $43.61
      Was: C $54.52
      C $27.26 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Johnny Unitas Colts Signed 2000 Topps Archives 1967 Reprint #133 PSA 10 Card

      Johnny Unitas Colts Signed 2000 Topps Archives 1967 Reprint #133 PSA 10 Card

      C $613.31
      Was: C $735.98
      C $26.88 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Multi signed HOF mini helmet w/ insc UNITAS MARCHETTI PARKER BERRY DONOVAN MOORE

      Multi signed HOF mini helmet w/ insc UNITAS MARCHETTI PARKER BERRY DONOVAN MOORE

      C $1,361.59
      or Best Offer
    • RAYMOND BERRY Signed 3x5 Index Card-BALTIMORE COLTS-Hall of Fame-PSA

      RAYMOND BERRY Signed 3x5 Index Card-BALTIMORE COLTS-Hall of Fame-PSA

      C $32.70
      Was: C $40.87
      C $23.58 shipping
    • Rare JOHNNY UNITAS Signed 8x10 Ron Lewis LE Artwork-HOF-BALTIMORE COLTS-PSA

      Rare JOHNNY UNITAS Signed 8x10 Ron Lewis LE Artwork-HOF-BALTIMORE COLTS-PSA

      C $218.06
      Was: C $272.58
      C $29.09 shipping
    • Bert Jones PSA DNA Signed Baltimore Colts 8x10 Autograph Photo

      Bert Jones PSA DNA Signed Baltimore Colts 8x10 Autograph Photo

      C $46.34
      C $19.08 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • JOE NAMATH signed NEW YORK JETS v BALTIMORE COLTS Super Bowl III 16x20 Photo PSA

      JOE NAMATH signed NEW YORK JETS v BALTIMORE COLTS Super Bowl III 16x20 Photo PSA

      C $442.96
      C $57.58 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • JOHNNY UNITAS Signed 8x10 Vintage Image Jumping Action Photo Baltimore Colts HOF

      JOHNNY UNITAS Signed 8x10 Vintage Image Jumping Action Photo Baltimore Colts HOF

      C $183.93
      C $40.82 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Lenny Moore 1960 Topps Baltimore Colts HOF Signed Auto Card #3 ~ PSA/DNA Slab

      Lenny Moore 1960 Topps Baltimore Colts HOF Signed Auto Card #3 ~ PSA/DNA Slab

      C $95.34
      C $22.27 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • RAYMOND BERRY , COLTS  AUTOGRAPHED GOAL LINE ART CARD PSA/DNA

      RAYMOND BERRY , COLTS AUTOGRAPHED GOAL LINE ART CARD PSA/DNA

      C $68.15
      or Best Offer
    • JOHNNY UNITAS BALTIMORE COLTS SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED 8X10 COLOR PHOTO PSA/DNA COA

      JOHNNY UNITAS BALTIMORE COLTS SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED 8X10 COLOR PHOTO PSA/DNA COA

      C $245.32
      C $32.21 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Raymond Berry Signed Goal Line Art Card GLAC Autographed Colts PSA/DNA AL85320

      Raymond Berry Signed Goal Line Art Card GLAC Autographed Colts PSA/DNA AL85320

      C $34.01
      or Best Offer
    • Lenny Moore Baltimore Colts Football Autographed 1956 Topps Card PSA SLAB

      Lenny Moore Baltimore Colts Football Autographed 1956 Topps Card PSA SLAB

      C $95.39
      C $22.48 shipping
    • JOHNNY UNITAS Signed PSA/DNA BABY DOE Mining Company 5 x 7 Picture SLABBED Colts

      JOHNNY UNITAS Signed PSA/DNA BABY DOE Mining Company 5 x 7 Picture SLABBED Colts

      C $177.17
    • Raymond Berry autographed signed 8x10 photo NFL Baltimore Colts PSA COA

      Raymond Berry autographed signed 8x10 photo NFL Baltimore Colts PSA COA

      C $38.16
      Was: C $47.70
      C $27.26 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • JOHNNY UNITAS SUPER BOWL V CHAMPS AUTOGRAPHED SIGNED FOOTBALL PSA/DNA #F49272

      JOHNNY UNITAS SUPER BOWL V CHAMPS AUTOGRAPHED SIGNED FOOTBALL PSA/DNA #F49272

      C $340.72
      C $53.43 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Original Autograph PSA/DNA of Art Donovan of the Balt. Colts on a small Photo

      Original Autograph PSA/DNA of Art Donovan of the Balt. Colts on a small Photo

      C $102.15
      C $9.54 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Original Autograph PSA/DNA of Art Donovan of the Balt. Colts, 8x10, headshot, #7

      Original Autograph PSA/DNA of Art Donovan of the Balt. Colts, 8x10, headshot, #7

      C $102.15
      C $9.54 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • JOHNNY UNITAS & ARTIST SIGNED AUTOGRAPH FRAMED 11X14 LITHOGRAPH PHOTO COLTS PSA

      JOHNNY UNITAS & ARTIST SIGNED AUTOGRAPH FRAMED 11X14 LITHOGRAPH PHOTO COLTS PSA

      C $305.44
      Was: C $339.37
      C $58.59 shipping
    • Johnny Unitas 3x5 Index Card PSA/DNA Encased Autograph Slight trace

      Johnny Unitas 3x5 Index Card PSA/DNA Encased Autograph Slight trace

      C $190.74
      C $17.77 shipping
    • LENNY MOORE Signed Goal Line Art Card PSA Slabbed Autograph BALTIMORE COLTS

      LENNY MOORE Signed Goal Line Art Card PSA Slabbed Autograph BALTIMORE COLTS

      C $68.15
      C $30.24 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Baltimore Colts HOF PSA Multi-signed Mini Helmet Unitas Donovan Moore Berry

      Baltimore Colts HOF PSA Multi-signed Mini Helmet Unitas Donovan Moore Berry

      C $1,634.18
      or Best Offer
    • Jim Parker Signed Goal Line Art Card GLAC Autographed Colts PSA/DNA AL85311

      Jim Parker Signed Goal Line Art Card GLAC Autographed Colts PSA/DNA AL85311

      C $54.45
      or Best Offer
    • Jimmy Jim Duncan Signed Index Card (d.72) Colts Saints Football Autograph PSA

      Jimmy Jim Duncan Signed Index Card (d.72) Colts Saints Football Autograph PSA

      C $408.82
      C $25.81 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Original Autograph PSA/DNA of Art Donovan of the Balt. Colts, 8x10, headshot, #5

      Original Autograph PSA/DNA of Art Donovan of the Balt. Colts, 8x10, headshot, #5

      C $102.15
      C $9.54 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Original Autograph PSA/DNA of Art Donovan of the Balt. Colts, 8x10, headshot, #8

      Original Autograph PSA/DNA of Art Donovan of the Balt. Colts, 8x10, headshot, #8

      C $102.15
      C $9.54 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Gino Marchetti Signed FDC First Day Cover HOF PIGSKIN PIONEERS NFL AUTO 1997 PSA

      Gino Marchetti Signed FDC First Day Cover HOF PIGSKIN PIONEERS NFL AUTO 1997 PSA

      C $53.14
      Was: C $81.76
      or Best Offer
    • JOHNNY UNITAS Signed Auto Baltimore Colts 16X20 Photo PSA/DNA COA!

      JOHNNY UNITAS Signed Auto Baltimore Colts 16X20 Photo PSA/DNA COA!

      C $1,022.20
      C $48.56 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • SIGNED Johnny Unitas Photo PSA/DNA Certified - Baltimore Colts AUTOGRAPHED John

      SIGNED Johnny Unitas Photo PSA/DNA Certified - Baltimore Colts AUTOGRAPHED John

      C $538.36
      C $25.75 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • 1957 Topps Jim Mutscheller #103 PSA / DNA Certified Authentic P1233

      1957 Topps Jim Mutscheller #103 PSA / DNA Certified Authentic P1233

      C $38.16
      C $22.28 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • JOHNNY UNITAS Signed Auto Baltimore Colts 16X20 Photo PSA/DNA COA!

      JOHNNY UNITAS Signed Auto Baltimore Colts 16X20 Photo PSA/DNA COA!

      C $1,020.85
      C $48.53 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Norm Bulaich Baltimore Colts Auto Signed 8x10 Vintage Magazine Photo PSA

      Norm Bulaich Baltimore Colts Auto Signed 8x10 Vintage Magazine Photo PSA

      C $27.19
      C $20.70 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • TOM MATTE SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED INDEX CARD CUT PHOTO BALTIMORE COLTS PSA

      TOM MATTE SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED INDEX CARD CUT PHOTO BALTIMORE COLTS PSA

      C $66.78
      C $15.91 shipping
    • Art Donovan Signed Goal Line Art Card GLAC Autographed Colts PSA/DNA AL85337

      Art Donovan Signed Goal Line Art Card GLAC Autographed Colts PSA/DNA AL85337

      C $34.01
      or Best Offer

    Results Pagination - Page 1

    1. 1
    2. 2
    3. 3
    4. 4

    Additional site navigation

    • About eBay
    • Announcements
    • Community
    • Security Centre
    • Seller centre
    • Policies
    • Help & contact
    • Site Map
    Copyright © 1995-2023 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. User Agreement, Privacy, Payments Terms of Use, Cookies and AdChoice