36,000+ results for used rare
- Rushton Cat Star Creations Rare Rubber Face RareOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $75.001 bid · Time left5d 14h+C $57.00 shipping
- Rushton Clown Rare Early Rubber Face Plush Doll. Star Creations No Tag .Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $75.001 bid · Time left5d 14h+C $58.00 shipping
- Rare Antique Steiff Teddy Bear Golden Mohair Hair Straw Filled Middle Seam MetalOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $615.17from United States
- Disney's Vintage Star Bean Scrooge McDuck Plush Stuffed 8" Used Rare Toy SmallOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $40.97from United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Rare Donald Duck Folkmanis Hand Puppet Retired Disney 5007Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $799.00+C $70.00 shipping
- Plants vs Zombies PvZ Plush Peashooter "Head Zombie Set" Used RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $27.33from United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Vintage Care Bears Canvas Purse Bag Tote 1980s Case Merch Toy Rare UsedOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $16.24Was: C $24.9935% offTop Rated Seller
- Claire the Cow Squishmallow Stackable Purple Squish Used RareOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $273.40from United States
- TCC Global MEGAMIND Plush 12" Big Headz 2010 DreamWorks Used RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $82.02+C $33.90 shippingfrom United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Domo Plush 5.5 Pink Sock Cap (RARE, W/ TAGS) - UsedOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $47.83from United States11 watchersTop Rated Seller
- Plants vs Zombies PvZ Plush LINXIN CHERRY-BOMB Original 2011 Used RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $41.01+C $23.24 shippingfrom United StatesTop Rated Seller
- 8” Valentine’s Philippe The Frog Squishmallow Gently used Rare 2017Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $180.87from United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Jellycat BASHFUL OTTER MEDIUM Rare & RetiredOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $43.753 bids · Time left6d 15hfrom United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Zip Chip Tippy Monkey Rushton Star Creations Magician Rare Rubber FaceOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $95.000 bids · Time left6d 23hC $550.00Buy It Now+C $64.00 shipping
- Squishmallows Bethany the Unicorn Koala 14" 2020 RareOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $132.09+C $22.63 shippingfrom Australia
- Plants vs Zombies PvZ CATTAIL PLUSH K/O Light Green Plant Base Used RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $27.34+C $23.24 shippingfrom United StatesTop Rated Seller
- lisa raccoon plush toy Rare 1980s The raccoons CartoonOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $150.00+C $14.00 shippingTop Rated Seller
- Mundi Brazil Vintage Leather Elephant Midcentury Plush Rare Stuffed AnimalOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $109.35from United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Vintage SANDY 24K Polar Puff Special Effects 1990’s RARE Plush Dog 4131, 7 InchOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $28.69Top Rated Seller
- Vintage Peacock Watchimal - RARE! 1985 Hasbro Softies No WatchOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $25.00Top Rated Seller
- rare Rudy The Pitbull douglas dog plushOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $250.000 bids · Time left6d 20hC $400.00Buy It Now
- Vintage Rare Cititoy My Baby Dinosaur Plush Baby Sinclair 1990Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $50.00Free shippingTop Rated Seller
- Plants vs Zombies PvZ Plush LINXIN WALL-NUT Original 2011 Used RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $27.34+C $23.24 shippingfrom United StatesTop Rated Seller
- RARE 12” KELLYTOY Luigi Plush 2001 Nintendo (Needs Work)Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $135.34from United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Plants vs Zombies PvZ PEASHOOTER Plush 7" 2010's K/O Used RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $24.61+C $23.24 shippingfrom United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Leosco Lying Timber Wolf 18” , RareOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $273.410 bids · Time left5d 11hor Best Offerfrom United States
- RARE 1940s' GUND 20" PLUSH DREAMIE CAT HARD TO FINDOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $410.100 bids · Time left2d 6h+C $60.85 shippingfrom United States
- Rare Vintage FAO Schwarz Brian Froud Goblin Plush - Mohawk - Scheer Stuffed ToyOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $341.75from United StatesFree returnsTop Rated Seller
- Bear in the Big Blue House Tutter Mouse Plush Star Bean MATTEL RARE Jim HensonOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $102.53from United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Vintage Rare!! Squares stuffed bear Large Plush Display Advertising Toy Rare!!!Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $417.12Top Rated Seller
- Plants vs Zombies PvZ Plush WORLDMAX PIRATE ZOMBIE 12" Doll 2013 Used RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $73.82+C $33.90 shippingfrom United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Gund Rushton? Star Creations? Devil Rubber Face Plush 1950s Rare Halloween 26Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $1,367.050 bids · Time left4d 15hfrom United States
- Squishmallows Lala The Lamb 8” RareOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $105.00+C $18.00 shippingTop Rated Seller
- 1995 Universal City Studios Balto Plush Toy Movie Wolf Dog Rare VintageOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $170.871 bid · Time left1d 13hfrom United States
- Plants vs Zombies PvZ Plush PvZ Plush LINXIN SPLIT-PEA Original 2011 Used RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $32.81+C $23.24 shippingfrom United States10 watchersTop Rated Seller
- Squishable Plush Orange Golden Chinese Dragon 15" Very RareOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $217.36+C $61.41 shippingfrom United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Ganz Heritage Collection Ratzo Rat Hand Puppet Plush 12” Vintage 1988 NICE! RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $159.00Top Rated Seller
- Vintage Hansa White Siberian Tiger Laying Floppy Plush Stuffed Animal 2004 RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $81.95from United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Rare Canadian plush Regal Toys Ltd. JawaOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $700.000 bids · Time left9d 6hC $1,000.00Buy It NowFree shipping
- Vtg 1964 My Toy Rubber Face Bunny Rabbit Plush Green Pants Flower Feet HTF RareOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $136.690 bids · Time left3d 16hfrom United States
- Wheelo Blue Bunny Rare!Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $15.04from United StatesTop Rated Seller
- RARE Vintage Ganz Bros Canada Teddy Bear Yellow Brown Plush Red Bow 1980’sOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $14.99Top Rated Seller
- RARE *USED* Webkinz Signature Arctic Fox *NO CODE*Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $314.41from United States
- Vintage Hasbro Pony Surprise Playful Hair Purple Ponies RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $59.99Top Rated Seller
- Vintage Rare 1998 Stan South Park Comedy Plush Stuffed ToyOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $70.00+C $18.00 shippingTop Rated Seller
- Pokemon 1998-2000 Plush Nintendo Hasbro Bean Bag Toy TOTODILE Super Rare VintageOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $49.9910 watchers
- Rare Steiff 1959 ERIC The Bat Mohair Felt Ornament With Original TagOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $65.625 bids · Time left4d 4h+C $24.62 shippingfrom United States
- Jim Henson Fraggle Rock Plush 8” Doozers Flange In Box Hasbro Softies RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $499.95+C $29.99 shippingTop Rated Seller
- Steiff Owly Owl Plush 045165 Rare 9.5" Tag MissingOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $65.00Free returns
- Domo Sock Monkey Plush RareOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $25.91+C $15.31 shippingfrom United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Vintage 1981 Applause Owl Plush 7" Rare with Tag Sad Knickerbocker RARE HTFOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $47.71+C $23.27 shippingfrom United States
- 2007 Disney Kingdom Hearts II Roxas 12" Plush Pre-OwnedOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $35.95+C $33.86 shipping
- Rare Small 5” Sanrio Smiles Chibimaru Plush With LeashOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $232.40+C $32.34 shippingfrom United States23 watchers
- RARE Disney Think Pink Mickey & Minnie Mouse Plush Disney Store ExclusiveOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $68.34+C $49.39 shippingfrom United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Sid Ice Age Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Yellow Sloth Mattel RARE!Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $15.99from United States
- Rare Douglas Black & White English Pointer Dog 12" x 15" Plush PuppyOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $307.59from United States13 watchersTop Rated Seller
- Rare Squishmallow Food 8 Inch Scarlet the Strawberry Soft Plush EUCOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $17.76from United StatesTop Rated Seller
- 1995 Nanco Plush - Blue Dragon Stuffed Animal Toy 6” Used RARE NYOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $32.78+C $15.52 shippingfrom United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Designo Dinos Aeroba Saurus Totsy Toys 1987 Very Rare HTF Dinosaur FlockedOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $79.99Top Rated Seller
- Jellycat Large Amuseable Croissant 18” 45cm RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $68.35from United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Used-RARE Jakks Pacific 2008 Neopets 7" Scorchio Dragon w/Princess Outfit* PlushOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $15.75from United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Rare Paw Patrol Apollo Super Hero Puppy Dog Plush Stuffed AnimalOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $19.99+C $20.00 shippingTop Rated Seller
- Rare Steven Smith Plush Polar Bear 11” - Realistic PoseOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $13.60from United StatesTop Rated Seller
- BronyCon 3 LARGE Mascot Plush 2015 15" Blank Canvas, Hoof Beatz, Mane Event RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $169.510 bids · Time left2d 6hfrom United States
- Bertwin Squishmallow 16 inch yellow bearded 2022 *new*never used*rare*exclusiveOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $20.51from United States
- stretchkins Frog RareOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $47.83from United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Minecraft Moobloom Plush Yellow Cow Buttercup Flower Pillow Stuffed Toy RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $87.15from United StatesTop Rated Seller
- SUPER RARE Kellogg's Fruit Twistables Mascot Sargeant Twistable Plush Doll ToyOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $205.06from United StatesTop Rated Seller
- Items Per Page