Skip to main content

Include description

12,000+ results for halloween toy cat

0 results found in the Everything Else category, so we searched in all categories
Squishmallows Twizzlers Autumn 8" Plush Cat Halloween Hershey Stuffed KellyToy
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $35.00
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
or Best Offer
quichka (1,422) 100%
+C $18.00 shipping
Halloween Cat Toy Bloody Knives Interactive Catnip Filled Teething Chew Toys
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $15.08
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
pokepanths (667) 99.5%
from United States
SmartyKat Halloween Stimulation Cat Toy Catnip Fish & Skitter Mouse
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $27.76
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Was: C $30.84 10% off
ceriamiatoe (2,925) 99.5%
or Best Offer
+C $15.42 shipping
from United States
NEW! KITTY CRITTER SPIDER CAT TOY HALLOWEEN PLUSH w/ PREMIUM CATNIP CRINKLE
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $16.81
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
dhockeyb (75,602) 100%
+C $12.35 shipping
from United States
House Of Blues Black Cat Creepy Halloween Decor Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Doll
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $32.93
my_junk_for_your_cash (1,100) 100%
or Best Offer
from United States
Squishmallow Halloween Plush 5" Vampire Cat Cam 2022 Plush Stuffed Animal
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $8.99
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
jamibaros (267) 94.1%
Free shipping
Catarina The Cat Halloween Squishmallow 2020 Black Pink 8 Inch No Bio Tag GUC
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $14.00
sfindsm99 (127) 97.6%
or Best Offer
New ListingOld Celluloid Halloween Black Cat With Jointed Tail
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $34.29
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
0 bids · Time left6d 12h left (Thu, 11:00 a.m.)
more-gojunkster (306) 100%
from United States
New ListingRuss Halloween Smokey the Cat Witch 8" Li'l Peepers Stuffed Plush
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $8.23
americanherotoys (17) 100%
Buy It Now
from United States
New ListingAntique 1930s Tin Litho Halloween Noisemaker Clicker US Metal Toy Owl Cat x 10
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $310.01
9finds (69) 100%
or Best Offer
from United States
Littlest Pet Shop #1679 Halloween Cat
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $21.95
taycre23 (20) 100%
0 bids · Time left16h 20m left (Fri, 03:19 p.m.)
from United States
Autumn The Cat Squish Doo 4” Capsule Squishmallow Halloween BNWOT
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $3.00
maegemaclea-0 (54) 100%
or Best Offer
Fiesta Halloween Black Cat Kitty Halloween Plush Toy Wire Poseable Tail 9" Body
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $17.77
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
dscrybe (2,940) 100%
from United States
AXEL PETS 20 Halloween Colorful Mice Cat Toys Rabbit Fur with Catnip Rattle
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $21.94
axel_pets (3,193) 100%
Buy It Now
+C $20.27 shipping
from United States
Snuggie Toy 10" Halloween Black Cat Orange Bow Plush Stuffed Animal NWT
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $15.42
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Was: C $20.57 25% off
mandrflips4you (2,479) 99.8%
or Best Offer
+C $23.97 shipping
from United States
Bunnies By The Bay - Halloween Kitty 'Boo Boo', Soft Toy, Cat, Plush Animal, ...
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $30.63
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
mightymerchantau (1,199) 100%
+C $22.55 shipping
from Australia
LOOSE McDonald's 2000 Crazy Bones LUCKY CAT Kitty Monster Halloween COLOR CHOICE
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $6.86
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
mcjantone2 (75) 100%
+C $21.32 shipping
from United States
McDonald's 1990s Vintage Halloween Toys-Pick!
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $6.86 to C $16.46
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
yoda3535 (1,793) 99.7%
from United States
McDonald's 2019 HELLO KITTY Sanrio Halloween Cat Costume Figure YOUR Toy CHOICE
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $4.12 to C $10.98
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
mcjantone2 (75) 100%
+C $21.45 shipping
from United States
McDonalds Happy Meal Toy #2 Halloween Birdie Black Cat 1998 Sealed
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $13.69
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
or Best Offer
fabter-90 (348) 100%
from United States
UnderCover Mouse Interactive Cat Toy, 2 in 1 Function (Halloween)
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $27.43
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
daeheelee (2,836) 100%
+C $20.42 shipping
from United States
Plush Halloween Shelf Sitter Cat
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $36.02
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
mr.deezflips (4,329) 100%
from United States
Momentum Brands Halloween Black Cat Rubber Duck Yellow Bill NWT Bath Toy
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $10.96
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
or Best Offer
leopardspot (3,183) 99.6%
+C $21.93 shipping
from United States
Last one
1 watchers
Kellytoy Black Cat Plush Halloween Purple Bow 10" Stuffed Animal Toy
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $22.23
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Was: C $24.70 10% off
2010samiraj (2,246) 100%
or Best Offer
+C $20.27 shipping
from United States
KONG Kickeroo Mouse Catnip Cat Toy ~ Halloween Patterns
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $13.65
giftedpet (3,690) 100%
Buy It Now
+C $15.00 shipping
from United States
New ListingBlack Cat Stuffed Plush Ball Pet Baby Toy Halloween Spooky Gift Stuffer
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $25.40
countymercantile (23,921) 100%
0 bids · Time left9d 15h left (05-19, 02:31 p.m.)
or Best Offer
+C $32.26 shipping
from United States
McDonalds Happy Meal Toy #2 Halloween Birdie Black Cat 1998 Sealed
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $8.44
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Was: C $10.29 18% off
jukeboxlinds (958) 99.8%
or Best Offer
from United States
Squishmallow Cleo Cat 12" Witch Hat Potion Halloween Canada BNWT
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $39.95
that_toy_shop (107) 100%
or Best Offer
Free shipping
Disney Catnip Cat Toys Halloween Crinkle
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $10.29
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
shopitemsforyou (106) 100%
+C $21.76 shipping
from United States
PussinBoots Kitty Softpaws Puss Funny Cat Halloween Plush Toys Cuddly Doll Gifts
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $29.62 to C $49.38
ge46966 (4) 100%
Was: C $54.87 10% off
Buy It Now
+C $9.59 shipping
from China
Pumpkin cat toy with catnip crochet handmade amigurumi halloween toy, 2pcs
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $34.30
anasargo (463) 100%
Buy It Now
+C $9.59 shipping
from Portugal
SALEM the Plush BLACK CAT Stuffed Animal - by Douglas Cuddle Toys - #4394
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
5.0 out of 5 stars.
5 product ratings - SALEM the Plush BLACK CAT Stuffed Animal - by Douglas Cuddle Toys - #4394
C $32.86
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
douglas_cuddle_toys (7,809) 99.8%
+C $15.57 shipping
from United States
92 watchers
Fiesta Black Cat Kitty Soft Plush Halloween Stuffed Animal with orange Bow
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $17.15
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
greatbuy21 (872) 100%
+C $21.97 shipping
from United States
Birdie Black Cat w Hamburglar Mask Halloween Candy Dispenser Figures 4 McDonalds
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $16.46
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
or Best Offer
the-cheerful-nest (3,948) 99.8%
+C $21.76 shipping
from United States
Cat Toy Brush And Collars Bundle Halloween Cute Multiple Cat
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $12.35
starrstuffy (24) 95%
or Best Offer
from United States
Catarina The Cat 4” Squishmallow BNWT Capsule Halloween 2023 Shoppers Canada
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $7.00
maegemaclea-0 (54) 100%
or Best Offer
McDonalds Haunted Halloween Candy Dispenser Birdie Cat 1998 Happy Meal Toy New!
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $8.22
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
or Best Offer
tyhifive (2,333) 100%
+C $22.39 shipping
from United States
New ListingAphmau MeeMeows Hallowen Cat Kitten 11" Plush Stuffie Werewolf Grey Cat Face
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $27.37
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
wizardrealmresales (1,672) 99.9%
from United States
Free returns
Mary Meyer Sweet Rascals Halloween Black Cat Plush Witch Hat 2003 9 Inch Stuffed
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $137.14
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
or Best Offer
gizmorf (28,572) 100%
+C $26.81 shipping
from United States
Aphmau HALLOWEEN Plush 11" AUTHENTIC PUMPKIN CAT
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $104.91
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Was: C $116.56 10% off
moochiepikachu (5,736) 100%
Buy It Now
+C $25.92 shipping
from United States
Halloween Black Cat Plush with Sound Kitty JStuff Associates Stuffed
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $16.45
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
or Best Offer
whiskerz85 (1,135) 100%
from United States
McDonalds Happy Meal Toy #2 Halloween Birdie Black Cat 1998 Sealed
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $6.85
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
or Best Offer
packratcollectables (1,082) 100%
+C $19.32 shipping
from United States
McDonald’s Happy Meal Toy #1 1998 Halloween AM HUNGRY Collectible Cat
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $5.49
amooseslooses (1,791) 100%
or Best Offer
+C $23.32 shipping
from United States
Black Dracula Cat Plush Stuffed Toy Halloween Tickle Wiggle Working
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $18.52
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Was: C $20.58 10% off
misstinabanina (1,232) 100%
or Best Offer
from United States
Set Of 2 1993 Burger King Nightmare Before Christmas Watches Bats Cats Halloween
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $13.69
emb0524 (949) 100%
Was: C $27.37 50% off
or Best Offer
from United States
Kellytoy BLACK CAT Plush Pumpkin Costume Halloween Bean Bag Stuffed Animal
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $37.03
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
0 bids · Time left5d 20h left (Wed, 07:30 p.m.)
toyswithapast (45,995) 99.7%
+C $15.70 shipping
from United States
X's 3 Vo-toys Cat Catnip Halloween Toy Pumpkin Glitter Balls 4 Pack Autumn Fall
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $19.19
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
bennynv (63,071) 99.7%
+C $15.16 shipping
from United States
SmartyKat Catnip Fish (Set of 3) Halloween Catnip Cat Toys
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $10.96
carspal0 (188) 100%
or Best Offer
from United States
Squishable Undercover Kitty Plush Pumpkin Costume Black Cat Stuffed Animal Toy
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $20.58
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
or Best Offer
xxtailesxx (967) 99.3%
from United States
McDonalds Happy Meal Toy #2 Halloween Birdie Black Cat 1998 Sealed
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $19.21
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
or Best Offer
caylan199 (2,697) 99.8%
+C $20.65 shipping
from United States
Vtg Sears Exclusive Halloween Friday The Black Cat Witch Plush Stuffed Toy Tags
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $25.00
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
or Best Offer
snazzylabels (309) 100%
+C $18.00 shipping
New ListingSquishmallows 4” Black Purple Kitty Cat AUTUMN Plush Capsule HTF Rare
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $34.23
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
lpsrose (2,788) 100%
+C $24.70 shipping
from United States
Vintage 1993 McDonalds Purple Witch Cat Trick or Treat Bucket Pail Halloween
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $6.86
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
skeezmonkee (750) 100%
from United States
Vtg Sears Halloween Friday Black Cat Orange Witch Hat Plush Bat Stuffed Toy NWT
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $34.99
digdigwowwow (51) 100%
or Best Offer
+C $12.99 shipping
Hug Fun Halloween Teddy Bear Cat Costume 2004 Plush Stuffed Toy
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $12.35
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
Buy It Now
cycoamber65ak (7,312) 99.8%
+C $32.70 shipping
from United States
12" Autumn The Halloween Kitty Cat Squishmallows Stuffed Plush
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $24.68
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
or Best Offer
ashleyisnotgreen (199) 100%
+C $28.80 shipping
from United States
SmartyKat Bouncy Mouse Cat Toy Bungee Toy Halloween Frankenkitty
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $4.12
chris.cover (270) 96.7%
Buy It Now
from United States
Mouse Mice Cat Toy Set Halloween (2 Pack) by Hyde & EEK! Boutique New
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $17.15
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
or Best Offer
idiscountresale (3,888) 99.7%
+C $15.11 shipping
from United States
6 watchers
Vintage 1989 Hardee's Hideaway Halloween Smooshies! Lot Of 2 Bat & Cat
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $12.33
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller
or Best Offer
bjibelejime (659) 100%
from United States
Halloween Black Cat Dressed as Pumpkin Jack o' Lantern Plush Kitty Toy 7"
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $9.87
rareuniqueweirdorunusual (16,339) 99.9%
Was: C $10.96 10% off
or Best Offer
from United States
Results Pagination - Page 1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Items Per Page
120Items Per Page
240Items Per Page