315 results for beanie baby rare
- RARE RETIRED 1995 TY BEANIE BABY TWIGS THE GIRAFFE WITH PVC PELLETS/ERRORSOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $27.36from United States
- NIP Antsy The Anteater McDonalds ty Teenie Beanie Baby #2 Rare with Errors 1999Opens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $44.46Top Rated Seller+C $15.87 shippingfrom United States
- Retired TY Beanie Baby WISE The 1998 Owl Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Rare BeanieOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $12.98Top Rated SellerWas: C $13.67 5% off+C $26.57 shippingfrom United States
- TY Beanie Baby ULTRA RARE signed #82/100 Shooting Star Harrod's Ex. (AJ11545)Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $1,025.96Top Rated Seller+C $32.83 shippingfrom United States14 watchers
- TY Millenium The Bear Mcdonalds Beanie Baby 1999 Vintage Plush Rare RetiredOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $13.68from United States
- TY Beanie Baby RARE signed by TY - Scared-e the cat (AJ11546)Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $540.34Top Rated Seller+C $32.83 shippingfrom United States11 watchers
- CHOCOLATE the Moose ❤️ A1 1st Gen Tush Tag TT NHT❤️ Rare Original TY Beanie BabyOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $41.04Top Rated Sellerfrom United States
- Gemmy plush the grads unused great condition rare toy GraduationOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $60.00+C $25.00 shipping
- Unusual Brown Bear ⭐ Orignal Boyd's Bears ⭐️Very Rare 1st Gen Tush TagOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $41.04Top Rated Sellerfrom United States
- TY BEANIE BABY STRUT THE ROOSTER 1996 W/TAG RARE RETIRED VINTAGEOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $6.22Top Rated Seller0 bids · Time left6d 22hC $14.43Buy It Nowfrom United States
- TY Beanie Baby MTY - Bear Brown OLD FACE RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $362.51from United States
- Rare Wizard of Oz Branded Beanie Babies Collectible Complete BundleOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $54.72+C $21.16 shippingfrom United States
- 1996 Ty “Peace” Beanie Baby Retired - RARE P.E. PelletsOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $273.59from United States
- 1998 HALO Angel Bear Ty Beanie Baby - Rare/Retired/Errors, Great Condition!Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $102.60from United States
- Authentic TY Beanie Baby WISE the owl class of ‘98. Retired. Rare. Tag errors.Opens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $136.79from United States
- Kerby Avon Bear Brand New complete 1983 Retired Rare VintageOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $250.00+C $50.00 shipping
- TY Beanie Baby "Hissy" with rare Tag Errors vintageOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $6.830 bids · Time left4d 8hor Best Offerfrom United States
- Ty Beanie Baby “Ariel” with Tag Errors. Rare And Retired. Light Green Color.Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $273.59+C $33.57 shippingfrom United States
- Beanie Babies Wise The Owl Plush Rare See Photos For Printing ErrorsOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $10.88Top Rated Seller0 bids · Time left6d 19hC $19.08Buy It Nowfrom United States
- STEG-Canadian 3/1 COOL COLORS MWMT.. CERTIFIED .(RARE)Opens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $478.78from United States
- RARE Husky Dog Princess Cruises Beanie Baby: Brand NewOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $6.83from United States
- Kuku Beanie Baby 1997 1998 Multiple Tag Errors RareOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $2,000.00+C $25.00 shipping
- Pair Of McDonald's size Ty Beanie Baby Millennium bears Rare Year 2000Opens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $30.00Free shipping
- DANBURY MINT DACHSHUND HALLOWEEN WITH LIGHTS NEW CONDITION RETIRED RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $547.18from United States13 watchers
- Ty Beanie Baby Authenticated Master Card II RARE Black nose signed (AJ11544)Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $820.77Top Rated Seller+C $32.83 shippingfrom United States10 watchers
- RARE #'d 408/500 "KERMODE" Y2K Senna Bears Beanie Canadian Test "Ghost Bear"1999Opens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $99.95+C $10.00 shipping
- Ty Beanie Baby "Seamore" original 1993 Retired RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $547.18from United States
- Ty Beanie Baby Ty2K Bear Confetti RARE With Tag Errors, Retired Acrylic CaseOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $444.58Top Rated Seller+C $46.35 shippingfrom United States
- 5 Beanie baby rare, collection PEACE,TEDDY,1999 BEAR ,ERIN,VALENTINA with tagsOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $177.83from United States
- RARE, Ty McDonald's Maple The Bear Beanie Baby July 1, 1996 WITH ERRORS NEWOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $82.08Top Rated Seller+C $35.65 shippingfrom United States
- RARE VINTAGE TY BEANIE BABY "PERIWINKLE THE BEAR" 2000 RETIREDOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $41.04Top Rated Sellerfrom United States
- ULTRA RARE SUPER UNIQUE HOPE Beanie Baby With ERRORSOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $700.00Free shipping
- RARE RETIRED Ty Beanie Baby "Wiser" The Owl Class of 1999 w/Tag Errors MWBMTSOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $16.42from United States
- Super Rare Betty Boop Love 2005 Hearts & Kisses Beanie Baby With TagOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $14.98Top Rated Seller0 bids · Time left3d 6hfrom United States
- Authentic TY Beanie Baby WISE the owl class of ‘98. Retired. Rare. Tag errorsOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $1,300.91from United States
- Union Pacific Beanie Baby “ Goldie” Very Rare! Beautiful golden with red ribbonOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $34.19Top Rated Sellerfrom United States
- Bennie Baby Rare Rangers Retired Limited EditionOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $109.44+C $43.30 shippingfrom United States
- TY original “ERIN” Beanie Baby 1997 P.E. Pellets Rare with ErrorsOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $150.47from United States
- HUGE Lot of 25 Unopened Avon Beanie Babies from 1998 1999 2000 RARE!! NOT TY!Opens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $67.03Top Rated Sellerfrom United States
- Rare Hush puppy Used with tags Born 1958Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $54.65Top Rated Sellerfrom United States
- Rare Must See Union Pacific Beanie Baby For Collectors! Comes With Display CaseOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $41.02Top Rated Seller+C $21.57 shippingfrom United States
- Ty CHECKERS Panda Bear Beanie Babies 1993 Ty Attic Treasures VINTAGE RARE NEWOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $5.40Top Rated Seller0 bids · Time left9d 14hC $8.14Buy It Now+C $24.91 shippingfrom United States
- Vintage Ty Beanie Babies Maple the Bear Canada Exclusive with Tags Rare HTFOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $27.35Top Rated Sellerfrom United States
- [Extremely rare, limited to 10 pieces! In excellent condition] Sailor extra largOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $1,415.49Top Rated SellerWas: C $1,489.98 5% off+C $13.68 shippingfrom JapanFree returns
- Rare Retired 1999 schweetheart Ty Beanie Baby With tag ErrorOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $116.28from United States
- Vintage MdDonald's Teenie Beanie Baby Osito 2000 French Canadian ~RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $13.68Top Rated Sellerfrom United States
- Luke the Dog - 1999 Ty Original Beanie Babies - Rare/Retired - Free Shipping!Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $13.61Top Rated Seller+C $14.95 shippingfrom United States
- Retired TY SPANGLES & GLORY Beanie Baby Very Rare w/ Errors? 1998Opens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $41.02Top Rated Seller0 bids · Time left6d 5h+C $36.50 shippingfrom United States
- Vintage Ty beanie baby plush 1995 doll grunt the razor back bore pig plush rareOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $40.70Was: C $47.88 15% off+C $32.17 shippingfrom United States
- RARE TY Beanie Baby CLAUDE The Crab RETIRED 1996 MINT condition multiple errorsOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $13.67from United States
- M&Ms Rare Branded Beanie Babies Collectible BundleOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $41.04+C $20.77 shippingfrom United States
- TY Beanie Baby Halo Bear with Several Errors. Retire & RareOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $272.22from United States
- Vintage Applause Hush Puppies April Plush Puppy of the Month - Scarce RareOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $75.24Top Rated Seller+C $21.78 shippingfrom United States
- RARE Bears "Justin" Timberlake NSYNC LIMITED EDITION Collectors #7157 of 25000Opens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $10.93Top Rated Sellerfrom United States
- MWMT MQ Authenticated RARE 4th gen "KOREAN" RADAR - Ty Beanie BabyOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $205.18+C $36.55 shippingfrom United States
- SpongeBob Window Buddy Suction Cup Hands Screaming RareOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $16.42Top Rated Sellerfrom United States
- [RARE, VTG] Peanut Elephant Light Blue Beanie Baby - Includes Oakland A’s CardOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $34.13Top Rated Sellerfrom United States
- Hopper the Rabbit - 2000 Ty Original Beanie Babies - Rare/RetiredOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $13.67from United States
- Rare Must See Union Pacific Beanie Baby For Collectors! Comes w/Display Case VTGOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $41.02Top Rated Seller+C $21.57 shippingfrom United States
- Boyd’s Bears - Rare, Gray Nose, Binkie Bear. Black and White Tush and Hang Tag!Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $102.60from United States
- Rare 1995 Retired Tabasco Beanie Baby p.v.c pellets errors 1st gen hang tagOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $174.41Was: C $205.19 15% off+C $30.64 shippingfrom United States
- Rare “my Collectables Original Beeny Friend” TY KnockoffOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $15.00+C $22.00 shipping
- NASCAR Jeff Gordon #24 Beanie Baby Bear Rainbow Warrior Flames Vintage Rare 1999Opens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $57.45Top Rated Seller+C $16.25 shippingfrom United States
- Mint Rare Retired 1997 1998 TY Wise Graduation Owl Beanie Baby Tag ErrorsOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $552.31Was: C $649.78 15% offfrom United States
- RARE The Penguins Of Madagascar Kowalsky Plush Dreamworks Nickelodeon ViacomOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $82.06from United States
- Ty Beanie Baby Princess Diana Purple Bear 1997 With Tag Cover RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-OwnedC $1,095.70Top Rated Seller+C $27.36 shippingfrom Japan
- Authentic TY Beanie Baby WISE the owl class of ‘98. Retired. Rare. Tag errors.Opens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $41.04from United States
- Mint Rare 1997/98 TY Wise Owl Beanie Baby W/ Tag Protector And Has Tag ErrorsOpens in a new window or tabBrand NewC $102.60from United States
- Items Per Page
![[Extremely rare, limited to 10 pieces! In excellent condition] Sailor extra larg](https://i.ebayimg.com/thumbs/images/g/sLwAAOSw7S5mFKxi/s-l140.jpg)
![[RARE, VTG] Peanut Elephant Light Blue Beanie Baby - Includes Oakland A’s Card](https://i.ebayimg.com/thumbs/images/g/SbEAAOSwmzxlVdcw/s-l140.jpg)
