Skip to main content

Include description

17,000+ results for cookie cutters vintage

New ListingVintage Wilton Barbie Cookie Cutters New
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $13.65
or Best Offer
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellertripic_43 (783) 99.3%
Vintage Halloween Cookie Cutter Set 1950’s With Box Trick Or Treat
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $13.67
or Best Offer
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerbigelktreasures (727) 100%
New Listing6 WILTON EASTER Love Cookie Cutters eggs, chick, & bunny Vintage 1997 Plastic
Opens in a new window or tab
C $6.82
Buy It Now
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerjulestreasurefinds (382) 100%
Lot of 120 Vintage Assorted Aluminum & Plastic Holiday Cookie Cutters
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $135.29
0 bids · Time left3d 2h left (Thu, 04:46 p.m.)
or Best Offer
+C $23.53 shipping
from United States
teamre3 (34) 100%
Simon’s Cooper Cookie Cutter - Duck Vintage! NIB!
Opens in a new window or tab
C $384.01
19 bids · Time left4d 15h left (Sat, 05:29 a.m.)
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellertundra200712 (4,197) 99.6%
Cookie Cutters Lot of 16 Aluminum Vintage Horse Lion Bell Heart Turkey Tree Star
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $10.93
Buy It Now
from United States
redloveskg (11,580) 99.5%
Metal Barnyard Cooky Cutters 7/12 cookie cutters in box vintage
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $8.88
or Best Offer
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Selleratumber (6,740) 100%
Vintage W. ROBERTS Tin Cookie Cutters Flat Back Christmas Tree
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $6.83
1 bid · Time left5d left (Sat, 02:25 p.m.)
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerarnoldsattic40 (1,455) 100%
Vintage Miniature Metal Cookie Cutters For Christmas 1455
Opens in a new window or tab
C $6.83
0 bids · Time left17h 14m left (Tue, 07:10 a.m.)
or Best Offer
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerjf_farm (1,226) 100%
Vintage HF Tin Cookie Cutters Flat Back Christmas Lot of 3 Santa Stocking Angel
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $20.50
1 bid · Time left5d left (Sat, 02:19 p.m.)
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerarnoldsattic40 (1,455) 100%
New ListingVintage Large Michael Bonne Flag Copper Cookie Cutter
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $107.96
0 bids · Time left9d 2h left (05-22, 04:54 p.m.)
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellercherokeecreek (1,048) 100%
Vintage Metal Tin Cookie Cutters Lot Of 9
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $18.00
or Best Offer
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerquiksilversurfer79 (778) 98.2%
Vintage Halloween Cookie Cutters, metal, bat, cat, witch, JOL, owl, 1960's
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $13.65
0 bids · Time left1d 19h left (Wed, 09:00 a.m.)
or Best Offer
+C $25.87 shipping
from United States
kevindanz (128) 100%
New Listingvtg lot of metal cookie cutters baking holiday decor
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $15.29
Was: C $19.1220% off
or Best Offer
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellervintagefarmhouse (9,056) 99.9%
Cookie Cutters ~ Lot of 17 ~ Copper Color Aluminum ~ Vintage
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $27.26
or Best Offer
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerrjmittenmerch (226) 97.7%
4 Vintage Hallmark Valentine's Cookie Cutters
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $28.70
or Best Offer
from United States
4 watchers
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerkaahls47 (454) 99.7%
New ListingLot Of 7 Vintage Aluminum Cookie Cutters Various Shapes Bunny Rotary Germany
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $34.10
Buy It Now
+C $22.38 shipping
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller120frogger (1,878) 100%
Vintage (2) Round Aluminum Biscuit Cookie Cutters, Green/Red Wood Handles
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $17.75
or Best Offer
from United States
dragonlady094-3 (2,026) 100%
HUGE EXTRA LARGE STAR COPPER COOKIE CUTTER 9 Inches Vintage With Handle
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $88.83
0 bids · Time left5d 3h left (Sat, 05:00 p.m.)
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerweki_1749 (315) 100%
Vintage Mini Pastry Cookie Cutters 4” Metal Storage Tin Biscuit Veggie Lot of 8
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $29.07
Buy It Now
+C $23.94 shipping
from United States
ccruzjc3 (3,667) 100%
Cookie Cutters Animal Shapes Made in Hong Kong 8 Piece Lot Vintage 1980's
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $15.99
or Best Offer
+C $9.99 shipping
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellersilver_tree_collectables (430) 99.1%
Antique Vintage Primitive Flat Back Tin Cookie Cutters - Lot of 15
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $34.17
or Best Offer
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellermrsslpep (4,233) 100%
11 VINTAGE METAL COOKIE CUTTERS IN ORIGINAL BOX - XMAS, ANIMALS, HEART, AXE
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $9.99
Buy It Now
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerluanne5072 (3,034) 100%
LOT OF 6 VINTAGE ALUMINUM HOLIDAY COOKIE CUTTERS
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $16.40
Buy It Now
+C $20.49 shipping
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellergina3397 (4,756) 100%
Vintage HRM CROWN USA Red Plastic COOKIE CUTTERS Set Of 13 Christmas
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $35.53
Buy It Now
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Selleropal-pie (302) 100%
Vintage WILTON MONSTERS! MONSTERS! Cookie Cutter Set 1990
Opens in a new window or tab
New (Other)
C $4.10
Buy It Now
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerslb06 (1,726) 100%
Vtg Tin Metal Cookie Cutter Shapes Set of 7 Gingerbread Horse Star Snowman
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $21.95
or Best Offer
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerlivinginharmony8 (2,213) 100%
VINTAGE Aluminum Cookie/Biscuit Cutters with Green Wood Handles Set of 9
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $23.23
0 bids · Time left5d 6h left (Sat, 08:52 p.m.)
C $41.00
Buy It Now
+C $22.81 shipping
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Selleryankeesilversmith (970) 100%
Vintage Nativity Scene Bake Set Christmas Metal Cookie Cutters Instructions
Opens in a new window or tab
New (Other)
C $55.42
or Best Offer
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellermangoleny (3,741) 100%
3 Vintage Biscuit Cookie Cutters Rumford Metal Soldered Handle EUC
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $28.40
Was: C $35.4920% off
or Best Offer
from United States
thefrugalzinnia (152) 97.7%
Lot of 29 Vintage Aluminum Cookie Cutters - Animals Chicken Santa Xmas Tree ++
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $29.12
or Best Offer
+C $45.22 shipping
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerzebra3113 (3,329) 100%
Vintage Empire Christmas Cookie Cutters NEW SEALED
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $14.99
or Best Offer
+C $4.99 shipping
Free returns
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Selleradampatricbeato-0 (2,217) 99.6%
Old Formay Vintage Pressed Steel Tin Rabbit Halliday Easter Bunny Cookie Cutter
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $6.82
0 bids · Time left5d 17h left (Sun, 07:22 a.m.)
+C $20.90 shipping
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerscottketch71 (18,590) 99.7%
Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters Box Set for all Party Occasions 1940s
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $23.90
or Best Offer
+C $20.24 shipping
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerscioseller (2,349) 99.9%
Vintage Red Translucent Cookie Cutters - YOU PICK - HRM | Loma | Unmarked
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $3.07 to C $11.55
Buy It Now
from United States
myheavenandstars (263) 100%
HRM New Vintage Design Plastic Cookie Cutter Set of 8 Nativity Creche Christmas
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $34.10
Buy It Now
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellernewponder (6,368) 100%
Easter Cookie Cutters. 6 Vintage Cookie Cutters. Made Of Metal In Original Box
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $13.67
0 bids · Time left3h 7m left (Today 05:02 p.m.)
or Best Offer
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerpleasantviewfindings (642) 100%
Vintage HRM Cookie Cutters Set of Nine 1940's Red Plastic
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $20.47
or Best Offer
+C $24.69 shipping
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Selleryoco.2015 (638) 100%
Vintage Goldilocks Teddy Bears 4 Cookie Cutters Box Storybook Collection 1985
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $15.72
Buy It Now
+C $29.35 shipping
from United States
the.hunt (2,180) 100%
Train Set Cookie Cutters Lot Of 4 Fox Run Engine Coal Passenger Car Vintage 1984
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $10.86
or Best Offer
from United States
grius26 (958) 99.7%
Vintage Lot 6 Aluminum Cookie Cutters - Santa, Horse, Bunny, Stars, Hen, Leaf
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $13.65
or Best Offer
from United States
supercat2k2 (46) 100%
Vintage Lot 26 Cookie Cutters Aluminum Copper Holiday Mini Large
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $17.77
Buy It Now
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerthevelvetelvis (558) 99.5%
Vintage 1950’s Doll Size Cookie Cutters
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $5.47
Buy It Now
from United States
zeke2983 (49) 100%
Vtg Miniature Cookie Cutters Lot Of 12- Dog, Horse, Chicken, Cat, Lion & Rabbit
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $16.40
0 bids · Time left21h 23m left (Tue, 11:18 a.m.)
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerterrisemidriven (2,198) 100%
Vintage Aluminum Cookie Cutters Wood Handle Lot Of 4 Farmhouse, Country,
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $15.36
Was: C $19.2020% off
or Best Offer
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerrobertscleaning2009 (1,874) 99.7%
Lot of 4 Vintage Christmas Metal Cookie Cutters with Handles. gingerbread angel
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $15.02
or Best Offer
+C $28.63 shipping
from United States
amygo7404 (1,467) 98.5%
New ListingSnowman Aluminum Cookie Cutter w/ Handle Christmas Winter Snow Shape Vintage
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $13.58
Buy It Now
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerthethriftytriple (1,487) 100%
Vtg Halloween Original 1940’s-50’s Trick Or Treat 6 Metal Cooky(cookie) Cutters
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $20.49
Buy It Now
from United States
michiganthrift (894) 99.5%
3 HRM Vintage Red Plastic Cookie Cutters Nativity Mary Joseph Jesus In Manger
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $6.83
Buy It Now
from United States
fleafindings (13,930) 100%
Vintage Amscan Cookie Cutters Set of 5 Yellow Translucent Easter Hong Kong
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $9.55
Buy It Now
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellertoniah-half (7,033) 99.7%
Lot of 3 Mini Child Size Metal Cookie Cutters Vintage Animals
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $20.50
Buy It Now
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellertpowel64 (991) 100%
U Pick & Choose Lot: Vtg Antique Tin Metal Aluminum Cookie Cutter Handle Animal
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $1.35
Buy It Now
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerattictreasuresfleamarket (3,858) 99.4%
Vintage Aluminum Christmas Cookie Cutters - Santa, Tree Angel
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $12.29
Buy It Now
from United States
13 watchers
801kim435 (887) 100%
VTG Patriotic 4 Piece Cookie Cutters Eagle USA Abraham Lincoln George Washington
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $27.26
Buy It Now
+C $22.18 shipping
from United States
willi9590 (422) 100%
Vintage Lot of 13 Red Hard Plastic Cookie Cutters Christmas Animal Clown Deer
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $22.75
Buy It Now
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Selleropal-pie (302) 100%
Acme Vtg Metal Cookie & Sandwich Cutters Christmas & Dainty Bridge Boxed Sets
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $24.95
or Best Offer
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellermbtreasurehunter (972) 100%
Jif Holiday Cookie Cutters And Recipe Cards Vintage Merch
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $9.57
or Best Offer
from United States
jdcollectsnsells (80) 100%
2 Vintage Metal Round Biscuit & Cookie Cutters Rippled Edges with Handles
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $10.93
or Best Offer
from United States
hodge.kath (1,103) 99.8%
Vintage Cookie Cutters Lot Christmas Red & Green Imprint w/Handles Plastic
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $20.49
or Best Offer
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Selleramys_mom1984 (2,405) 100%
VTG Miniature Metal Cookie Cutters Christmas Set of 6 Sharp-Edged Original Box
Opens in a new window or tab
New (Other)
C $24.53
or Best Offer
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellermini_picks (609) 100%
New HRM Design Vintage Plastic Cookie Cutter - Merry Christmas Package Gift Bow
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $9.91
Buy It Now
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellernewponder (6,368) 100%
LOT 4 Vintage 1977 Sesame Street Muppets Cookie Cutters Wilton Hong Kong Yellow
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $11.49
or Best Offer
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Seller8two8vintage (3,394) 100%
VINTAGE ANTIQUE OLD MINIATURE COOKIE CUTTERS Mini Set of 5 Lion Horse Cat +++
Opens in a new window or tab
C $27.26
or Best Offer
+C $15.35 shipping
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerideahilldesigns (7,176) 99.7%
17 Vintage Cookie Cutter Lot Metal Plastic Various Holidays + 5 Face Stamps
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $6.83
Buy It Now
from United States
fleafindings (13,930) 100%
Tupperware Holiday Themed NIP Vintage White Cookie Cutters
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $10.52
Was: C $15.0330% off
or Best Offer
+C $21.69 shipping
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerliefema (1,248) 100%
New ListingVtg MCM Blue Circus Cookie Cutters Set of 5 Clown Camel Elephant Horse Donkey
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $10.92
0 bids · Time left6d 1h left (Sun, 03:00 p.m.)
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerponchosis (926) 100%
Vintage Aunt Chick's Merry Xmas 3D Cookie Cutters Set of 4 New Unopened
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $27.32
or Best Offer
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerjaybirdestate (2,214) 100%
Vintage Lot Of 9 Red Cookie Cutters "OLD MACDONALD'S FARM" Animals, Porky Pig
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $6.83
or Best Offer
+C $23.15 shipping
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerroyalcowboys (1,463) 100%
Cookie Cutters Assorted Shapes Lot of 14 Metal Vintage Holiday
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $16.40
or Best Offer
+C $30.94 shipping
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellertracerjaystrading (206) 98.7%
2 Vintage Tin Rooster / Chicken Flat Back Cookie Cutters
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $6.82
Buy It Now
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellervenicebeach275 (7,384) 99.8%
Cookie Cutters Assorted Shapes Lot of 15 Metal Vintage Holiday Christmas
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $10.93
or Best Offer
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellertreasuremaven1 (526) 100%
Vintage Biscuit Cutter Tin With Cutters / Antique / Biscuit Cutters
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $13.65
0 bids · Time left4d 2h left (Fri, 04:18 p.m.)
or Best Offer
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellerdia2646 (159) 99.4%
Vintage Aluminum Christmas Cookie Cutters With Handles Lot Of Four
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $13.67
or Best Offer
from United States
zorfan_0 (326) 100%
Vintage Lot of 10 Cookie Cutters Aluminum with Handles Animals Christmas Nature
Opens in a new window or tab
Pre-Owned
C $34.10
or Best Offer
+C $23.68 shipping
from United States
Top Rated SellerTop Rated Sellertheallisonboys (10,292) 99.7%
Vintage Cookie Cutters-Hartin-Plastic Christmas Lot of 3 New Packs 15 Total
Opens in a new window or tab
Brand New
C $28.97
or Best Offer
from United States
scoutsholidayhapiness (10) 100%
Results Pagination - Page 1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Items Per Page
120Items Per Page
240Items Per Page