Featured categories
Newly Listed
See all
Parents Choice Pink Unicorn Security Blanket Plush Baby Lovey Fluffy & Satin
C $24.79
Taggies Baby Toys Rattle Elephant and Giraffe Plush Stroller Clip Lot of 2
C $24.79
Cloud Island Golden Doodle Puppy Dog Security Blanket Baby Lovey Tan Cream
C $38.57
White Tiger Security Blanket Baby Lovey Minky Raised Dots
C $20.65
CR Gibson Teddy Bear Baby Lovey Security Blanket Tan Small 10"
C $24.79
Demdaco Puppy You Are Loved Plush Pippin Baby Lovey Stuffed Animal Gray
C $22.31
All items
Bobblehead Cat Cowboy Christmas Ornament Ceramic Kitsch
C $18.59
Parents Choice Pink Unicorn Security Blanket Plush Baby Lovey Fluffy & Satin
C $24.79
Taggies Baby Toys Rattle Elephant and Giraffe Plush Stroller Clip Lot of 2
C $24.79
ABERCROMBIE & FITCH NFL Dallas Cowboys Sweatshirt Gray Size M
C $92.99
Vintage Dundee Shirt Tales Baby Receiving Blanket Flannel
C $22.31
Jellycat Rumpus Puppy Dog Rattle Cream Brown Spots Small 8" Plush Baby Lovey Toy
C $34.71
Vintage Wamsutta Rainbow Pillowcase Standard Stranger Things Pride Faded
C $24.79
The Tweenies Bella Doll BBC Hasbro Blue Red Yellow Small 8" Toy
C $34.71
Peppa Pig Plush Stuffed Animal Doll ABD Ltd Just Play Small 8" Toy 2021
C $18.59
Build a Bear Teddy I Am Loved Plush Brown Make Wish Foundation
C $37.19
Build a Bear Smallfrys Hello Kitty Pink Polka Dots 7" Plush 2012
C $37.19
Carters Purple Butterfly Kisses Baby Blanket Heart Satin Snoozysnug
C $68.88
Vintage Baby Blanket Animal Blocks Pink Blue White Elephant Cat Bunny Bird Dog
C $55.79
Riley Blake Christopher Thompson Winifred Rose Bunny Fabric Pink 1 Yard Easter
C $18.59
Spark Create Imagine St Bernard Plush Puppy Dog Lying Down Brown White Walmart
C $18.59
Nat & Jules Fadley Fox Plush Lovey Blanket Mat Naturally Sweet Tan Plaid Demdaco
C $30.99
Baby Starters Blanket White Minky Raised Dots Satin 2015
C $37.19
Build A Bear Blue Sleeping Bag for Plush Teddy Camping Lizards Bugs BABW
C $18.59
Emotion Bear Blanket Mini Kaplan Early Learning Co Social Development Classroom
C $12.39
Cloud Island Golden Doodle Puppy Dog Security Blanket Baby Lovey Tan Cream
C $38.57
Ty Pluffies Quackies Duck Chick with Egg Plush Baby Lovey Easter 2005
C $18.59
Sorryimbusy Spellout Sweater Busy Baby Blue Women's Unisex Large
C $99.20
Saranoni Baby Blanket Blue Luxe Faux Fur Satin Trim Plush
C $37.19
Passover Needlepoint Canvas Judaica Jewish Art Made in Austria Vintage
C $24.79
IKEA Plush Heart with Arms Hug Kamratlig Red Small 5"
C $12.39
Pottery Barn Euro Pillow Sham Pillowcase Stonington Paisley New
C $30.99
Cloud Island Golden Doodle Puppy Dog Security Blanket Baby Lovey
C $37.19
Kellytoy Plush Dog Stuffed Animal Toy Tan Light Brown Floppy Lying Down 14"
C $22.31
Sperry Univac TASES Coffee Mug Sonar BAT Vintage IT Flight Computer System Rare
C $61.99
Creations of Grace Baseball Security Blanket Lovey White Red Minky Dots
C $43.39
Minky Couture Baby Blanket Pink White Chevron Rosettes Plush
C $49.59
White Tiger Security Blanket Baby Lovey Minky Raised Dots
C $20.65
Gund Bunny Justabunny Plush Musical Tan Rabbit Toy 36300 Small Easter
C $18.59
Angel Dear Pink & White Bunny Security Blanket Baby Lovey Closed Eyes Sleeping
C $18.59
Build a Bear Security Blanket Baby Lovey Plush Pink Rattle Heart Love
C $18.59
Carters Child of Mine DOLL Baby Lovey Navy Blue Dress Polka Dots Rattle Plush
C $18.59
Vintage Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Toy Blue Bow Tie Paw Pads 11"
C $43.39
Shopkins Candy Apple Purple Plush Stuffed Toy Rare New
C $37.19
Kellytoy Puppy Dog Stuffed Animal Plush Toy Green White Black Ears 10" 2013
C $37.19
Prestige Doll Little Ballerina Baby Lovey Pink Plush Satin Blonde 11" Flaw
C $18.59
Christmas Pin Brooch Enamel Sassy Lady Dangle
C $18.59
Pink White Gray Striped Elephant Security Blanket Baby Lovey Plush RN 36753
C $43.39
E&J Classic Plush Dog Cavalier King Charles Spaniel Brown 9" 2004 Cuddle Zone
C $37.19
Kids Preferred Doll Baby Lovey Pink Heart Stars Brown Hair 13" Plush 2010
C $21.07
Baby Gund Pink Puppy Dog Plush Take Along Lovey Stuffed Toy 14"
C $43.39
Playing Cards Outdoor Adventure National Parks On Every Game Card Deck Of 52 New
C $13.77
Lufthansa Airline Duck Bird Baby Lovey Plush Security Blanket Knots Stripes
C $43.39
IKEA Dolphin Genomblot Small Gray White Stuffed Animal Plush Toy 11"
C $20.65
About us
Welcome to The Lost Lovey Store! I'm here to help you find that item your child just can't live without! I offer baby blankets, security blankets, baby loveys, plush toys, and stuffed animals--things that are so important to our little ones. My inventory usually contains vintage baby blankets and plush toys as well, because no matter how old we get, sometimes it's delightful to have a nostalgic piece of our childhood. Can't find what you're looking for? Let me know, and I might be able to help you. Check back often; I add new inventory almost every day!
Store policies
Shipping
Seller feedback (7,447)
- 2***m (84)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseFast shipping, great packing, secure blanket as described, and great for the value.
- k***t (209)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseQuick and easy transaction. Nicely packaged and shipped quickly. As described and fairly priced. Thank you!
- 8***8 (3)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseItem arrived very quickly, great price! Item exactly as described. Packaged carefully.
- l***o (2047)- Feedback left by buyer.Past yearVerified purchaseGreat seller! Item as shown, quick shipping and very well packaged. Thanks!
- 6***a (1)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseThank you very much. grandsons “Sleepy Sloth” went missing. I thought I might find replacement online and my search lead me to eBay. The “ sleepy “ sent is pristine - looks brand new. Came a day quicker than stated and was packaged securely and arrived intact. Can’t say thank you enough!,,
- h***- (1)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseThis lamb is very important for my daughter (somone stoled her old one). So, this is worth everything for us, the shipping and the packing was good. This is in good condition as described.