Featured categories
Auctions ending soon
All items

MTG Judgment Booster Box Factory Sealed English Whmars9 FREE SHIPPING
C $658.2526 bids5h 16m

MTG Time Spiral Booster Box Factory Sealed English Whmars9 FREE SHIPPING
C $834.7924 bids5h 16m

MTG Saviors of Kamigawa Factory Sealed Booster Box English WhMars7 FREE SHIPPING
C $215.547 bids4d 5h 16m

Magic: the Gathering/MTG Poker Deck Yaquinto 1994 DCI Legend Whmars8 SHIPS FREE
C $13.671 bid5d 5h 16m

MTG 4x Kaya's Ghostform War of the Spark Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.90

MTG 4x End the Festivities Innistrad: Crimson Vow Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 4x Llanowar Elves Revised Edition Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG Black Lotus Sleeve WOTC Exclusive FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 4x Frogmite Modern Masters 2015 Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 4x Ossification Phyrexia: All Will Be One Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG Black Lotus Sleeve WOTC Exclusive FREE SHIPPING
C $20.53

MTG Kyren Toy Foil LP English Mercadian Masques FREE SHIPPING
C $20.53

MTG 4x Gray Merchant of Asphodel Theros Beyond Death 099/254 Unc. SHIPS FREE
C $8.21

MTG 4x Mirror Image Core Set 2019 Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 4x Ice Tunnel Kaldheim Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG Foil Cephalid Vandal Torment LP English FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 1x Breaker of Armies Battle for Zendikar LP Foil FREE SHIPPING
C $10.95

MTG 1x Dovin's Veto FNM Promos Foil LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 1x Pyretic Ritual Magic 2011 (M11) Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 1x Emblem - Tamiyo, the Moon Sage Avacyn Restored Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 4x Diabolic Tutor Magic 2014 (M14) Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $9.58

MTG 4x Imperious Perfect Commander Legends Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 4x Llanowar Elves 7th Edition Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG Duress Japanese - Strixhaven Mystical Archive - LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 4x Boros Charm Masters 25 LP Regular FREE SHIPPING
C $27.37

MTG 4x Reality Spasm – Rise of the Eldrazi 81/248 Regular Uncommon SHIPS FREE
C $8.21

MTG 1x Mother of Runes Urza's Legacy Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $9.58

MTG Trailblazer's Boots Zendikar 208/249 Regular Uncommon FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 4x Palladium Myr Core Set 2021 Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 4x Spidersilk Armor Mercadian Masques 273/350 Reg. LP Common FREE SHIPPING
C $10.95

MTG 1x Pyroblast Eternal Masters Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $9.58

MTG 1x Goblin Lackey Urza's Saga Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $27.37

MTG x4 Ghostly Flicker Avacyn Restored 57/244 Regular Common FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 1x Noble Hierarch Conflux Regular CON LP FREE SHIPPING
C $16.42

MTG 1x Windfall Urza's Saga 111/335 Regular Uncommon LP English FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 4x Last-Ditch Effort Urza's Legacy 83/144 Regular Uncommon LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG Triumph of the Hordes CHN-T 123/175 Regular Uncommon FREE SHIPPING
C $20.53

MTG 4x Red Elemental Blast 4th Edition Regular Common LP FREE SHIPPING
C $20.53

MTG 4x Fireblast Dominaria Remastered Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 4x Preordain Commander Legends Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $13.69

MTG 4x Goblin Archaeologist Darksteel Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 4x Lembas Lord of the Rings LOTR LOR Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 1x Once Upon a Time Throne of Eldraine Foil LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 1x Mindcrank New Phyrexia Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $16.42

MTG x4 Battle Hymn Avacyn Restored 128/244 Regular Common FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 4x Shepherd of Rot Onslaught 168/350 Regular Common FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 4x Feign Death Adventures in the Forgotten Realms Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21

MTG 4x Vampire Cutthroat Eldritch Moon 110/205 Regular Uncommon FREE SHIPPING
C $8.21
About us
Making Mythic is a gaming collectibles company selling primarily Magic: The Gathering and Dungeons & Dragons collectibles. We are owned and founded by former Wizards of the Coast staff. Most of our items come directly from former employees and their authenticity is guaranteed. (Please note: Making Mythic LLC is NOT affiliated with Wizards of the Coast.)
Seller feedback (1,657)
- o***o (47)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseTLDR - Wanted a NEO sealed set and that is exactly what I got. Next time I pick one up, I'll check here first. Postage as expected, Packaging no problems, and original wizards shrink wrap as you'd expect. As described: yes, will happily buy sealed sets from this company again Value: if you're looking at this you already know you're willing to spend this much money, don't lie to the review.
- e***f (184)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseI've bought from this seller at least a dozen times now and consistently have the same positive results. The product is exactly as described in picture. It gets packaged up very well send shipped out quickly. It took awhile to receive this order, but that was not the sellers fault. USPS was backed up due to weather.
- k***8- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchasePurchased Tuesday evening & Xanathar's was shipped first thing Thursday morning, individually sealed in a poly bag & then wrapped together with another book in the shipment with bubble wrap, before being placed snuggly in a cardboard shipping box. Shipping efforts were very much appreciated! Book arrived in great condition! I would buy from this seller again.
- m***n (14)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseAn excellent bulk box of MTG cards. Had a surprising amount of rares, foils, and older cards in it as well as a great variety of cards from several different sets. They also went noticeably above and beyond on the packaging. The bubble wrap and extra cardboard were a nice touch I wasn't expecting or needing, but it was greatly appreciated. Highly recommended seller. Excellent experience.
- o***i (2773)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseAs described, thank you. Solid value, packaged well and shipped on-time. Would be happy to do business with this seller again.
- p***o (194)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseA+++++ seller! Fast shipping, very good packaging. Item was new as described. Good communication & I will be glad to buy from him again.