Featured categories
Newly Listed
See all
Miami Dolphins New Era 9FIFTY Cap Hat Snapback Adjustable NFL Football
C $29.78
1990 Score JOE MONTANA NFL Collector Pin Series MVP Premier Edition Ace, NIB
C $9.70
derek jeter action figure
C $20.71
World Baseball Classic 2023 Rafael Devers Bobble Head
C $34.64
madame alexander dolls vintage
C $59.58
kewpie doll
C $27.71
All items
jefferson nickel set
C $124.70
Lenox snowman
C $11.07
1990 Score JOE MONTANA NFL Collector Pin Series MVP Premier Edition Ace, NIB
C $9.70
Jose Bautista Blue Jays Commerative Patch Card
C $5.54
Brass Christmas Tree Clock
C $5.54
Metal US Army Plane
C $5.54
kewpie doll
C $27.71
Padres Stamped Autograph Baseball
C $9.70
Miami Dolphins New Era 9FIFTY Cap Hat Snapback Adjustable NFL Football
C $29.78
Boston Red Sox Autographed Photos
C $41.57
madame alexander dolls vintage
C $59.58
Amish Knickerbocker Female Doll
C $10.39
Steph Curry Doll
C $34.64
Boston Celtics lot
C $55.42
Whimsy Christmas Block Child Set
C $69.28
2019-20 Panini Illusions - Clear Shots LeBron James #1
C $4.14
Boston Bruins Autographed Photo
C $27.71
World Baseball Classic 2023 Rafael Devers Bobble Head
C $34.64
2020-21 Panini Donruss Optic - Rated Rookie Tyrese Haliburton #162 Purple Prizm
C $9.70
Yankees Die Cast Car W Derek Jeter
C $24.94
2017-18 Panini Donruss - Rated Rookie Jayson Tatum #198 (RC)
C $34.63
coca cola matchbox cars
C $27.71
bruins tee shirt
C $24.77
vintage halloween candle holders
C $16.00
Batman And The Joker Dual Pop
C $41.57
VINTAGE Ertl, McDonald's Big Mac 1984 Car Toy Hamburger
C $4.16
Michael Jordan Children’s Sweatsuit
C $55.42
hamilton collection star trek plates
C $83.14
Centenary Commemorative Panels
C $24.94
2023 Panini Select - Concourse White Prizm Die-Cut #75 Saquon Barkley /199
C $7.83
Classic Winnie the Pooh w/Honey Pot & Spring Bee Christmas Tree Ornament w/Tag
C $13.86
Peyton Pritchard Rated Rookie
C $8.31
oh canada coins 2002
C $34.64
boyds bears and friends- Purrstone Collection
C $22.17
Yoda Doll
C $13.86
Tom Brady Macfarlane Figure
C $62.35
1982 Topps - #486 Ronnie Lott (RC)
C $11.08
Bon Scott AC/DC Figure
C $39.45
NFL Championship Checkers Game Set Board Game all 32 Teams New Sealed
C $18.71
millenium falcon
C $81.06
boston celtics card lot
C $138.56
Washington Redskins Matchbox
C $15.91
Minecraft roblox figures
C $8.31
John F. Kennedy JFK picture 3”pinback button pin
C $22.17
derek jeter action figure
C $20.71
Fred Plays with His Food Face 8.5” Plate
C $30.47
Jayson Tatum Doll
C $37.41
cherished teddies Wedding figurines lot
C $41.57
About us
Pa's Toy Attic specializes in used and new toys and collectibles. We specialize in Marvel, DC, Star Wars, sports, jewelry, coins, vintage books, comics, cards, clothing, dolls, and so much more. Browse the store for great gift and collectible ideas! Any purchase over $25 will include free gift (this months gift is Vintage McDonalds toy (unopened).
Seller feedback (42)
- 6***f (560)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseItem(s) received as described; smooth transaction and quick shipment; Well packaged; seller recommended; Great value; Thanks!
- t***b (3334)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseFast shipping, item looks good, packed really good, good value, a fantastic seller A++++
- 9***u (10)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseShipping was great packaging was good as described and good price
- b***j (5104)- Feedback left by buyer.Past yearVerified purchaseFast delivery , as described , packaged well , great value
- 0***u (175)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseFast delivery. Corresponds to the description. Good price. 10/10
- i***l (163)- Feedback left by buyer.Past yearVerified purchaseThe seller updated me when he shipped the angel and when I should receive it. I received it when promised, which was very quickly. The angel is as described - in excellent condition - and is very beautiful. Thank you!