Featured categories
Featured items
Best sellers
Top Picks
Popular
All items
Kitty Kitty Kitten Tyco 1992 Black White 6" Cat Pink Bow Blue Eyes Purrs *READ*
C $108.82
Care Bears Cousins Perfect PANDA 9" Plush Bear Black & White Stuffed NEW
C $27.20
Triple 5 Five Soul NYC Crossbody Bag Vtg Blue Orange 7" x 8" Nylon Zip Y2K Logo
C $168.70
Tupperware Lettuce Grapefruit Knife 3 Vtg Jadeite Green #885 Corer Gadget
C $12.23
Anchor Hocking Emerald Green Glass Hobnail 3 Footed 6.5" Vtg Candy Dish MCM
C $20.39
Victoria's Secret Satin Sleep Shorts Gold Label Vtg Blue Floral Size S Small
C $29.92
Disney STEAMBOAT WILLIE Mickey Mouse Bobblehead 2003 Black White Upper Deck
C $14.94
Hallmark Itty Bittys RAINBOW BRITE 4" Plush Stuffed Toy
C $10.86
Vera Bradley Pink Elephant Paisley Travel 6" x 4" Jewelry Case Inside Zip
C $23.11
Swung Glass Candle Holder Green Splash 4.25" x 2.5" Fingered Votive Trinket Dish
C $21.75
Dansko Women’s Ronda Corks Black Sandals Size 9.5 Eu 40
C $40.80
Aynsley Bone China Bluebell Time Vtg Yellow Gold Teacup Saucer #C493/7
C $34.00
Bella Taylor Wallet RFID Zip Around Accordion 7" x 4" Cards Daisy
C $21.75
Hank Williams Jr Cassette Tape Wild Streak 1988 Country NEW SEALED
C $8.15
McDonalds Halloween 1986 2 Pumpkin Bucket Pail McBoo McPunk'n Orange Vtg Lid
C $61.18
ELOPE Spider Black Widow Plush Hat 3D Costume Halloween
C $27.20
Rolex Golf Hat White Cap Crown Logo Green Adjustable Strapback Iconic Adult
C $115.62
Ty Beanie Babies 5" EEKS Bear Halloween Plush Purple Bat Costume
C $9.51
Plympton's Lucite Abalone Shell Resin Trivet 5.5” Hot Plate MCM Kitsch Round USA
C $27.20
Ty Beanie Babies LUAU PIG Pink 6" Plush Stuffed Animal NEW Tag
C $10.87
Jellycat Owl Beige White Fuzzy Woodland London 7" Plush Stuffed Animal
C $17.65
Crayola Crayons Ornaments 2 Christmas 90s Drum Organ Piano Bear Binney & Smith
C $14.95
Cast Metal 8" Blue Race Car & Red Motorcycle Vintage Set Wall Plaque Decor USA
C $29.92
Ashtray Red Lion MGM Grand Hotel Vegas Vtg Roaring Clear Glass
C $10.87
Charlie Puth NEW Sealed Vinyl LP 2022 Album
C $34.00
Sturgis T-shirt XL Buffalo Chip Motorcycle 100% Cotton 2011 Orange 30 Years
C $16.31
Funko Pop Disney #512 DREAMLAND DUMBO Elephant Circus Vinyl Figure 2018
C $6.79
Christmas 6 Vtg Round Cards 8” Circle Ornaments Dove Candles Without Envelopes
C $24.47
2 Wet n Wild Mascara Lash Renegade C145A Brazen BLACK Lot SEALED
C $14.95
Strawberry Shortcake CHILTON Plastic Play Plates Dish Vtg 13 pc Cups Pitcher USA
C $23.11
Mexican Turtle & Fish Painted Terra Cotta Mexico 4" Trinket Wide Mouth Yellow
C $27.20
TAMMIS KEEFE Tea Towel Vtg Pride of Kansas Beef Cattle Steer MCM Rare HTF
C $175.50
Vera Bradley PURPLE PUNCH Bifold Wallet Coin Pocket Zip 4" Quilted Cotton
C $17.67
Hallmark Purr-Tenders Cats Sock-Ems 1987 Hallmark Cards Plush Black White Tags
C $17.67
Harkerware Cup Saucer Cock O' Morn Yellow Daisy Lemon VTG Harker MCM USA
C $24.47
Arrowhead Vtg Atomic Style Melmac Set 8 Salad 7" Plates MCM Mid Century *READ*
C $216.31
Lug Kickflip SE Crossbody Bag RFID Kelly Green 7.75" x 4" Cards Zip Snap
C $54.40
Twin Six Women Cycling Jersey Size L Grand Prix Black Large 3/4 Zip
C $29.92
Wooden Match Box Holder Side Strike 5" Vtg Fruit Theme Wall Mount
C $16.31
Vtg Aladdin Red Cup Cap Lid for 60s Thermos with Metal Top - Lamp Logo CUP ONLY
C $65.98
CLIFFORD Big Red Dog 11" Puppet Hand Scholastic Plush Stuffed Animal Toy
C $10.87
Trevewood Mouse & Cheese 3.5" Salt & Pepper Shakers Vtg Souvenir Ceramic Pottery
C $14.94
Scooby-Doo Mystery Machine Vinyl Soft Lunchbox Cartoon School Saturday Morning
C $16.31
Vera Bradley BAROQUE Wallet Zip Quilted Black & Yellow Retired 7.5" x 4" Card
C $17.67
Joretta Headlee 1986 Christmas Hand Painted 11" Folk Art Santa Claus Signed
C $168.70
New Era 9Fifty Men Women Cap MLB Pittsburgh Pirates Basic Black Snapback Hat
C $34.00
Cassette Tape Rock Metal OZZY Osbourne Bark Moon & Night Ranger 1983
C $13.58
Lenox Sparkle & Scroll Reindeer Ornament Silverplate Multicolor Gems NEW
C $13.54
About us
Pupster Picker is named after my daughter's favorite plush and born out of my passion for thrifting. Hand chosen goods in my store are picked from antique malls, thrift stores and community sales giving a second life to vintage items! I am passionate about reuse and upcycling as a way to protect the environment and promote a sustainable lifestyle. To receive future promotions and sales notifications, please consider following and listing my store as a favorite. I list 4-6 new items in my store daily! My favorite items to source are vintage stuffed animals, toys for the 80s & 90s, Christmas decor and collectibles.
Seller feedback (962)
c***p (2841)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
This Lot of 4 Mattel Enchantimal Dolls arrived in as described "Excellent Used Condition". My granddaughter will be so excited to receive these adorable dolls! They were packaged with care and shipped quickly. I would definitely purchase from this seller again ~ Thank you!
r***q (44)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Item shipped super fast - same day I think! Well packaged, nice note inside. The item was just as described. Would happily purchase from this seller another time.
e***l (3060)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Item as described, packed well, fast shipping, would purchase from again. Thanks. A+++
o***t (186)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
Thank you! Trustworthy seller! Item arrived in great condition, as shown, very securely wrapped and packed.
2***4 (1137)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Awesome s’mores ornament. Well packaged and fast shipping! Great communication. Thank you and God bless.
a***a (192)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Received package today very happy with purchase, item as described thanks for wrapping item so no damage would occur during shipping.