Featured categories
Auctions ending soon
See allNewly Listed
See allFeatured items
Best sellers
All items

MANNY MACHADO 2010 1ST Bowman Chrome Draft Picks/Prospects #BDPP80 PSA 9 Mint^
C $57.710 bids6h 47m

JONATHAN TAYLOR Rookie 2020 Panini Green Prizm #332 SGC 9 Mint
C $26.110 bids12h 52m

BOOG POWELL 2002 Topps Archives Reserved 1969 Reprint #86 PSA 8 NM-MT
C $17.86

BRANDON NIMMO Auto 2001 Bowman Draft #BDPP63 BGS Auto Authentic
C $85.190 bids6h 44m

CALEB WILLIAMS Rookie 2024 Panini Neon Green Pulsar Prizm #301 SGC 9 Mint^
C $48.090 bids6h 48m

ANTHONY MUNOZ Auto Rookie 1982 Topps #51 Beckett BGS Auto 9
C $79.700 bids6h 46m

JAYDEN DANIELS Rookie 2024 Panini Mosaic Prizm #302 SGC 9.5 Mint+*
C $79.700 bids6h 46m

RAMON LAUREANO Auto Minor League 2017 Topps #3 Beckett BAS Authentic Auto
C $13.74

PHIL ESPOSITO BOBBY HULL BUCYK Auto (all 3) 1971-72 Topps #1 Beckett Auto 8
C $343.530 bids6h 39m

JORDAN LOVE Auto RC 2020 Panini Chronicles Black Prizm #PB-4 PSA/DNA Auth Auto
C $355.890 bids6h 39m

ANTHONY EDWARDS Rookie 2029-21 Donruss Pink Hyper Ottic Prizm #151 SGC 8
C $54.960 bids6h 48m

JUSTIN HERBERT Rookie 2020 Phoenix Fire Burst #103 SGC 9.5 Mint+
C $38.45

NOELVI MARTE Auto Prospect 2019 Bowman Platinum #TOP-67 Beckett Auto Auth
C $34.350 bids12h 50m

BOBBY HULL Auto 1976-77 O-Pee-Chee #100 Beckett BGS Authentic Auto
C $162.140 bids6h 42m

NANCY LIEBERMAN-CLINE Auto 1989 Sports Illustrated for Kids #101 PSA/DNA Auth
C $93.440 bids6h 43m

REBECCA LOBO Auto 1996 Classic Sears Legends of the Final 4 #3 Beckett Auto Auth
C $83.820 bids6h 45m

DOMINIC SMITH Auto Draft 2013 Panini Prizm #11 71/75 PSA 9 Mint New York Mets
C $39.85

ART MONK 1990 Fleer #164 PSA 9 Mint No Explanation of How Aquired
C $21.99

ALEX RODRIGUEZ Rookie 1995 Emotion #82 PSA 9 Mint Seattle Mariners
C $19.24

BOBBY ORR 1976-77 Topps #213 SGC 7.5 Near Mint+ Chicago Blackhawks
C $82.450 bids6h 45m

NANCY LIEBERMAN Auto RC 1997 Pinnacle Scoops #65 Beckett BGS Auto Authentic
C $85.190 bids6h 44m

MIA HAMM Auto 2004 SI for Kids #337 Beckett Auto 9
C $321.540 bids6h 41m

ANDREW ABBOTT Auto Rookie 2014 Topps #BSA-AA PSA 8 Near Mint to Mint
C $42.600 bids12h 49m

DEREK JETER MARIANO RIVERA 2011 Topps #424 PSA 9 Mint
C $17.860 bids6h 49m

MARVIN HARRISON JR Rookie 2024 Score #4 25th Anniversary PSA 9 Mint
C $17.860 bids12h 53m

HERSCHEL WALKER Auto 1987 Topps #264 Beckett BGS 9 Auto Dallas Cowboys
C $78.32

BRYAN REYNOLDS Auto 2022 Topps Silver Pack Series 2 Auto #T87C280 PSA 9 Mint
C $93.44

GUY LAFLUER Auto 1982-83 O-Pee-Chee #187 PSA/DNA Certified Authentic Auto
C $57.71

ANDREW VAUGHN Auto Rookie 2021 Topps Update Black #BSA-AV PSA 8 NM-MT
C $32.98

CAVAN BIGGIO Minor League 2018 Topps Heritage #132 PSA 10 Gem Mint
C $19.24

KYLER MURRAY Rookie 2019 Panini Elite Aspirations #106 Near Mint to Mint 89/99^
C $16.49

NOAH SYNDERGAARD Auto Prospect 2010 1st Bowman #BDPP75 PSA/DNA Cert
C $26.11

DAULTON VARSHO Auto Rookie 2021 Topps Chrome #RA-DV PSA 9 Mint/Auto PSA 8
C $41.22

CASEY MIZE Rookie 2021 Topps Now #67 PSA 10 Gem Mint
C $26.11

MATT MERVIS Auto Rookie 2023 Topps Purple Chrome #AC-MMV (205/250) PSA 8 NM-MT
C $27.48

MARSHALL FAULK 2000 Collector's Edge Graded Uncirculated #143 PSA 9 Mint 1/5000
C $16.49

JASSON DOMINGUEZ Minor League 2022 Choice #41 PSA 9 MT Hudson Valley Renegades
C $37.10

JASSON DOMINGUEZ Prospect 2021 Leaf Pro Set #PS-17 PSA 9 Mint
C $28.86

MICHAEL PENIX Rookie 2024 Panini Elite #125 133/999 SGC 9.5 Mint+
C $54.960 bids6h 49m

RUSSELL WILSON 2015 Panini Prestige #8 PSA 10 Gem Mint Seattle Seahawks
C $21.99

CONNOR BEDARD Rookie 2023-24 Upper Deck Star Rookies #1 Excellent^
C $10.99

YORDAN ALVAREZ Minor League 2018 Topps Heritage #111 PSA 9 Mint
C $17.86

ELI MANNING 2018 Panini Prizm #57 PSA 9 Mint New York Giants
C $20.61

BOBO BRAZIL 1982 Wrestling All Stars #32 Excellent to Near Mint
C $27.41

DAVE WINFIELD 1989 Bowman #179 PSA 8 NM-MT New York Yankees
C $16.49

JUSTIN HERBERT Rookie 2020 Panini Select #44 SGC 9.5 Mint+
C $24.71

CALEB WILLIAMS Prospect 2022 Bowman University Chrome #50 PSA 9 Mint
C $31.600 bids12h 51m

ANDREW BENINTENDI Prospect 2016 Bowman Chrome #BCP62 PSA 10 Gem Mint
C $20.61
About us
Tortugas Mountain Trading Company is located a no more than a rock's throw away from the sandy banks of the Rio Grande in southern New Mexico. We are avid sports fans who truly enjoy what we are doing. We strive to provide quality sports cards and collectibles at reasonable prices. We ship all purchases within one business day and provide risk-free, no questions asked returns for all merchandise sold.
We are a well-respected ebay seller with 100% customer satisfaction and are designated as an ebay Top-Rated Seller. We currently have over 730 cards listed and we are continually increasing our inventory. If you are a collector looking to consign your cards, let us know what you want sold, and we can provide you a quote for our services.
We are a well-respected ebay seller with 100% customer satisfaction and are designated as an ebay Top-Rated Seller. We currently have over 730 cards listed and we are continually increasing our inventory. If you are a collector looking to consign your cards, let us know what you want sold, and we can provide you a quote for our services.
Store policies
Shipping
Returns
Seller feedback (838)
- 0***u (185)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseLightning fast delivery, the item was packaged securely and safely. Item was priced fairly and came in the same condition described. Would highly recommend this seller, top notch communication, look forward to doing business with them again in the future.
- p***s (237)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseGood looking card.. conditions as described. Very well packaged. Fast delivery.. Great Seller!!
- f***l (291)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseI got a high quality card for my PC. It arrived in excellent condition as it was described. I love the appearance of the card and it was a good value. I would most certainly buy from this seller again.
- g***d (335)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseAs described. Very nice looking card. Well maintained. Packaged well for shipping. Thank you.
- l***l (360)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseGreat seller, fast shipping, well packaged A++
- a***t (237)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchasePackaged well. Arrived quickly. Item as described.