Product ReviewsThe Third Man (DVD, 2007, 2-Disc Set)

A Classic Beyond Dispute

What can you say? You get Carol Reed (director),Graham Green(script),Harry Lime(Orson Wells at his most flamboyant),Holly Martins (Joseph Cotton as the archtypal innocent American),steady Trevor Howard, lessons in Austrian pronunciation, great sewer shots--& oh that zither score by Anton Karas! One of the classic films that's both as serious & entertaining as its reputation for both. You don't have to think about either--you're just carried along by the pace & plot turns. And, as you might expect, it only gets better with repeated viewing. This is a collision of all collaborators working at their peak.
Incidentally, Criterion has lost the rights to this, so it's now officially out of print (June 2010). It will be picked up by Lionsgate (I believe)in a special edition scheduled for August or so, but right now--& probably whenever--this is the release to buy, if you can find it for a reasonable price.Read full review...

Called the greatest British film ever made

I can see why. Brilliant in every possible way! Carol Reed was one of the best directors ever, but sadly, only film buffs know his name. Add Welles, Cotton and Howard, and a thrilling Graham Greene script, and get ready for one of the masterpieces of cinema. Great extras on this Criterion release. Wish it hadn't gone out of print.Read full review...

Verified purchase:  Yes | Condition: new | Sold by: handhinc

The Third Man

What is so great about "The Third Man" and possibly the reason it has and will always remain a classic is the fact that a film like this can never be made again. Well at least not successfully. The setting of post WWII Vienna not only establishes the tone but is actually real location footage. How more authentic can you get! The casting too can never be assembled the way it was in this 1949 classic. Welles was extraordinary to say the least as Harry Lime while Joseph Cotten gives a performance of a lifetime. And of course the music. No production studio manufactured song could ever replace the zither music that stands its ground alongside the film as timeless. A true masterpiece and a gem in cinematic history.Read full review...

The Third Man

I bought this movie because it is the best British film of all time. It is the best of all foreign-made film noir movies. Great films are not planned, they occur by a chance meeting of great direction, cinematography, acting, script, musical score and etc. "The Third Man" contains all of these elements!

Carol Reed is a consummate director. In this movie, he combines a number of elements to give it a realistic atmosphere. He uses the city of Vienna as a grim backdrop to the plot. The destruction of World War II is apparent: bombed-out buildings, careworn people clearing the rubble, desperate survivors selling their possessions for life's necessities. Reed uses odd camera angles to show the convoluted and out-of-joint social conditions of post-war Vienna. Several Viennese actors and actresses have supporting roles. Certain landmarks are used in the film. All of these elements are used to give the movie a sense of realism.

Graham Greene's script crackles with sharp and sometimes witty dialog. The characters are fully developed. He traveled to Vienna in order to do the necessary research for the initial treatment of the plot. The script is devoid of platitudes and self-righteous morality. With the exception of Holly Martins (Lime's naive, American, pulp-novelist friend) the characters in the movie are amoral and greedy. The character of Harry Lime finally appears towards the end of the film which heightens the curiosity and the expectations of the viewer. Pursuing the elusive and wily Harry Lime through dangerous, shadowy post-war Vienna is like capturing a ghost. When the authorities come to arrest him, Lime descends to the sewer system like a cornered, frightened rat.

The principal actors and actresses, as well as supporting players, give outstanding performances. Joseph Cotten plays a naive, pulp-novel writer who is anxious to clear Harry Lime's name. He falls in love with Harry's girl friend (Alida Valli). He cannot believe that his friend is involved in the black market, but he reluctantly accepts his friend’s guilt. Trevor Howard (Major Calloway) relentlessly and single-mindedly pursues Harry Lime, despite the cost to himself and others. Bernard Lee is excellent as the major's assistant and body guard. Alida Valli gives a wonderful performance. As Harry's girl friend, she exudes a world-weary persona and remains loyal to him to the end. Orson Welles steals the show. He considered the part of Harry Lime as the best part that has ever been written for the screen. The producers paid big money for his involvement in the film and they got a their money's worth.

The musical score establishes the tone of the movie. Anton Karas's score is spirited but it lacks joy. As the plot thickens, the music grows more somber and more desperate. Robert Krasker's oscar-winning, lustrous photography makes good use of lights and shadows. It gives the film a expressionistic atmosphere.

The Criterion 2007, double-disc release is filled with great supplementary materials. I enjoyed the documentary on the making of this film. The print is pristine in quality, as clear and crisp as the Greene's screenplay. If you like black and white movies, you will not be disappointed with this release.

In summary, The Third Man embodies why I enjoy black and white movies. A well-written, directed, acted and produced film is like enjoying a good meal. Whenever I watch this movie, it is like being re-acquainted with a good, old friend.Read full review...

The Third Man 2 Disc Criterion (2007 re-release)

Astonishing improvement over the previous release by Criterion in every way. The image has been cleaned even more than Criterion's previous dvd, which was transferred from a Telecine Print, originally struck for Laserdisc in the 1990's. The Extras, including the new and insightful commentary with director Steven Soderbergh, (Sex, Lies, and Videotape, Kafka, Out of Sight, Traffic, The Limey, Ocean's 11) is a welcome addition. As is the volume new documentary material included on the second disc. NOTE: All original materials available on initial release, included on this re-release. 5 STARS !!!Read full review...

A Great Movie

The Third Man is a Great movie!!! In my top 5 all time!!! Beautifully filmed, directed, acted - everything! Some have called it a Perfect Movie and I agree!!

Verified purchase:  Yes | Condition: pre-owned | Sold by: hqmerit

Worth it

When i first got started with criterion titles, i wanted this one day 1, so i searched for a lo ng time for a afforable copy of this title and im happy i got it.

Verified purchase:  Yes | Condition: pre-owned | Sold by: bourbon_city_pi...

My 2nd favorite film

This is an exquisite remastering--with the original narration as well. Some nifty extra dvds.

THE THIRD MAN

PERFORMANCES OF ALL THE ACTORS IN THIS CLASSIC MAKE IT A MUST HAVE MOVIE. JOSEPH COTTON, ORSON WELLS, TREVOR HOWARD AND ALIDA VALLI ARE UNFORGETTABLE AS CHARACTERS BROUGHT TO LIFE FROM THE LINES WRITTEN BY GRAHAM GREENE. LOVE, MURDER AND MORE PLAYED OUT WITH POST WWII VIENNA AS THE BACKGROUND. THE THIRD MAN THEME IS AN UNFORGETTABLE MUSIC SCORE FROM THIS MOVIE.IF YOU HAVE NEVER SEEN THIS ONE ITS A SHAME. RENT IT,BORROW IT OR BUY IT AND YOU ARE GUARANTEED A MOVIE YOU WILL NEVER FORGET.Read full review...

the third man

the movie is a abstract and ununsal for its time. the music is so sinister and creepy all at the same time. I love Joesph Cotton and Orson Wells because they are two of the greatest actors in our lifetime. The give the movie the edge and also makes it mysterious at the same time . Amust see film.Read full review...